r5 <r5ahhj@r5ahhj.bounceme.net> wrote in message news:<r5ahhj-8132E1.18190411082004@newssvr23-ext.news.prodigy.com>...
> vktamhane12@rediffmail.com (V.K.Tamhane) wrote:
> > independent of any formula. It is for this reason that the concepts
> > and mechanisms are important in physics. Not to calculate results but
> > to actually understand the physics itself.
> 
> However, mathematics has been used to prove that your notions
> of physics are junk.

Fine illustration to the said in above posts. Well, you have a
possibility to demonstrate that your ideas are not junk. In
particular, in the discussed paper we showed that it is impossible to
calculate the current in unipolar generator, basing on Maxwell
formulation. If Maxwell formulation is true and the phenomenology does
not matter, please show this mathematically. ;-)

Sergey