Re: Gentlemen, I may have found the most ironic story yet
Eric Takabayashi <etakajp@yahoo.co.jp>:
> Rafael Caetano wrote:
> > Well, then they're really stupid, sorry.
>
> Insult the people who serve if you like, I will not.
> I will insult their leaders.
The leaders wreak havoc only so far as "the people who serve" follow
their orders. If you think these people are morally exempt because
they're following orders, well...
> > [reservists]
> > If they enlisted voluntarily in the Army, even if it was
> > 20 years ago, then they asked for it, no?
>
> No, they did not ask to go to Iraq, leaving behind jobs
> and families for a year or more, and they certainly did
> not ask to be disabled or die.
You have a strange view on what means to join the Army... but I give
up on this.
> I don't believe the average 18 year old is thinking about
> what can happen 20 years in the future or consequences of
> their actions. It's why young people do stupid things.
Agreed. They usually don't think about the consequences. But they
should.
> [Note: joining the military is not stupid.]
I respect your opinion (in Mencken's sense).
> We don't have compulsory service, and currently no draft.
>
> I am waiting to see what will happen if recruitment
> numbers fall as low as some people think they might,
> and the US is unable to maintain their presence
> in the Middle East with an all "volunteer" forces
Then I hope they would finally get their asses out of Middle East. But
I suspect that you disagree, so let's pass that... so, supposing that
US stays, and they can't get help from other countries. In that case,
do you support the draft?
> And if you are not one of those who support eliminating
> the draft or compulsory service,
Oh, but I do. I thought I had made it clear, sorry.
> then you are one of those who approve of the system, even
> if it means you being torn from your family, being shipped
> overseas, and dying, no?
No, I don't approve of that, Eric. That's why I said "I feel sorry
only if they are draftees".
(...)
> No, it shows morale is very poor. You do not want
> 100,000 people with poor morale and guns. You could get
> a Vietnam.
So what? That's what is bound to happen when a country invades every
"rogue" country in the world.
> You could also get some inhumane behavior.
??
[snip]
> > You can't claim you just want a job, and you don't know
> > or care for the consequences.
>
> For many, such as some members of minorities, military
> service is the BEST opportunity for training and jobs.
Sure, but you could say the same of some mafia jobs. Now, I suppose we
agree that mafia jobs are immoral. The problem is, I also think that
the Army is often immoral. The Iraqi war is unjust, for instance.
Apparently we disagree on this premise, so it's useless to discuss it
further.
(...)
> And if they are deployed to some war zone, I would expect
> them to do their duty and fulfill
> their responsibilities.
>
> And I would still feel sorry for them.
I see what you mean.
So let me give another example to make my position clear. Suppose
someone decides to become a fireman. He should be aware that he may
have to put his own life in danger many times in the future. Obviously
he can't claim afterwards, "Oh, but I didn't know it would be
dangerous". Even so, I would feel sorry if he died while working. Why?
Because his job is to save lives.
Now, do you really think that a soldier is like a fireman? Do you
believe that the wars (or conflicts, call it what you like) that US
has fought were all in the defense of the American citizens?
Rafael Caetano
Fnews-brouse 1.9(20180406) -- by Mizuno, MWE <mwe@ccsf.jp>
GnuPG Key ID = ECC8A735
GnuPG Key fingerprint = 9BE6 B9E9 55A5 A499 CD51 946E 9BDC 7870 ECC8 A735