YAMAGUTIseisei wrote:
> PR : $B%7%s%.%e%i%j%F%#7OM-NA%a!<%k%^%,%8%sH/9T$r9=A[CW$7$F$*$j$^$9(B
> $BL5NA%a!<%k%^%,%8%sHG(B ( $BJLESM-NAHG3+;O;~BG@Z(B )
> http://mailux.com/mm_dsp.php?mm_id=MM53D8AF3589BC7
> 
> 
> $B@_7W35MW<+BN$NBe$j$K<~JU>pJs(B ( $BO@J8K]LuEy(B ) $B$r$*FO$1CW$7$F$*$j$^$9(B
> 
> 
> 
> YAMAGUTIseisei wrote:
>>> $BBN:YK&(B : $B:YK&BN(B
>> $B:YK&AX(B : $B%;%k%i%l%$%d(B
>>> $BG[Ns(B : $B%7!<%1%s%9(B
>>> $B1s0Lu(B $B6a0Lu(B $B4pACu(B $B4pK\u(B $B@hC<u(B $BD:C<u(B $B?4@mu(B :
>>> $BKv>?u(B $Bu(B $B4pDlu(B $B4pDlu(B $B@mC<u(B $B@mC<u(B $B@mC<u(B ( $B@mu(B )
>>> : 
>>>>Google $BK]Lu(B http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083
>>>>
>>>>
>>> :
>>>> $B$J$<%K%e!<%m%s$O2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$C$F$$$k$N$+!"?7HiuFM5/!"%7!<%1%s%95-21(B
>>>>
>>>> $B$3$N869F$N%P!<%8%g%s$O!"(B2015$BG/(B10$B7n(B30$BF|8=:_$G8x3+$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B
>>>>$BCm0U$H$7$F?^$HI=$O$3$N(BPDF$B$N:G8e$K$"$j$^$9!#(B
>>>>$B:G?7$N0zMQ>pJs$K$D$$$F$O(B ry




$B$3$N869F$N%P!<%8%g%s$O!"(B2015$BG/(B10$B7n(B30$BF|8=:_$G8x3+$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B
? $B?^(B ry $B!#(B
$BCm0U$H$7$F?^$HI=$O$3$N(BPDF$B$N:G8e$K$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B:G?7$N0zMQ>pJs$K$D$$$F$OCx](B
$B?7HiuFM5/$NHs@~7AFC@-$,J#?t%Q%?!<%sG'<1$r%K%e!<%m%s$K2DG=$K$5$;$k;v$,0JA0$KDs0F$5$l$F$$$k!#(B
? $BK\9F$G$O!"%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$K1h$C$FG[CV(B ry $B%K%e!<%m%s$O!"$?$H$(BgNL(B ry $B%Q%?!<%s$NJQF0$,$"$C$F$b!"@53N(B ry $B$K:YK&3hF0$N2?I4$H$$$&FHFC$N%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$3$H$r3X$V$3$H$,$G$-$k$3$H$r<($9$3$H$K$h$C$F$3$N%"%$%G%"$r3HD%(B ry $B!#(B
$BK\9F$K1w$F$3$N%"%$%G%"$r!"%;%k%i%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$N2?I4$b$N%f%K!<%/%Q%?!<%s$r%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$K@0A3G[CV$5$l$??t@i$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$D%K%e!<%m%s$,Nc$(BgNL$N%N%$%:$d%Q%?!<%s%P%j%(!<%7%g%s$,$"$m$&$H$b@53N$K$=$7$F4h6/$KG'<1$9$k;v$r3X=,$9$k;v$,$G$-$k;v$r<($9;v$K$h$C$F!"2f!9$O3HD%$7$^$9!#(B
? $B$A$K@8@.$9$k$3$H$J$/!"(B ry $B$H$7$F5!G=$9$k!#(B
$B$=$7$F!"%K%e!<%m%s$K$h$C$FG'<1$5$l$?%Q%?!<%s$N$$$/$D$+$,3hF0EE0L$rM6H/$9$k%K%e!<%m%s%b%G%k!"$r2f!9$,Ds0F$7%K%e!<%m%s$N8EE5E*$C$F!"463P;I7c$H1?F0%7!<%1%s%9$H$NCf$NB?$/$N;~4VE*%Q%?!<%s$r3X$V$?$a$K2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$r%K%e!<%m%s$OI,MW$H$7$^$9!#(B

1$B!#(B $BA0=q$-(B
? $B?7Hi.$5$J1F6A$r;}$C$F$*$j$=$7$F!":YK&$N1~Ez$r2?@i$b$N1s0L%7%J%W%9$,7hDj$9$k$K1w$F=ELr$r1i$8$k;v$,$I$&$9$l$P2DG=$+!"$rA[A|$9$k$N$OD9G/:$Fq$G$7$?!J(BMajor et al$B!#!"(B2013$B!K!#(B
? ry $B;^$,G=F0E*$J=hM}MWAG$G$"$k$3$H$,$o$+$j$^$7$?!#(B
$BuFM5/$NJ,;^$,G=F0E*$J%W%m%;%C%7%s%0MWAG$G$"$k$H2f!9$O:#CN$C$F$$$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"6I=jE*$Ju(B ry $B%9%Q%$%/!"$*$h$S$=$N7k2L$H$7$F$NM-0U$G;}B3E*$JBN:YK&$NC&J,6K$r0z$-5/$3$92DG=@-$,$"$k!J(B ry $B!#(B
$B6u4VE*$*$h$S;~4VE*$K6a@\$7$?HO0OFb$G$N$$$/$D$+$N1s0L%7%J%W%9$N3h@-2=$O!"%m!<%+%kuFM5/(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/5Z$S$=$N7k2L$H$7$F!":YK&BN$NM-0U3n$D;}B3E*$JC&J,6K$rM6H/$9$k;v$,$G$-$k!J(BAntic$B$i!"(B2010$BG/(B; Major$B$i!"(B2013$BG/!K!#(B
$B$3$l$K$h$j!"uFM5/J,;^$,FHN)$7$?%Q%?!<%sG'<1AuCV$H$7$F:nMQ$9$k$3$H$r<(:6$9$k8&5fuFM5/(B ry $B$+$+$o$i$:!"$J$<%K%e!<%m%s(B ry $BHiuFM5/$NG=F0FC@-$rM}2r$9$k>e$GB?$/$N?JJb$,$"$C$?$K$b4X$o$i$:$=$N;v$O!"2?8N%K%e!<%m%s$,$=$s$J$KB?$/$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$C$F$$$k$N$+!"$=$7$F$=$l$i$N@53N$JLr3d$,5-21$*$h$SHiuFM5/$r;}$C$F$$$k$N$+$H$$$&M}O@(B ry $B%9%Q%$%/%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/(B ry $B;H$o$l$F$$$k$b$N$N$h$&$J!"(B ry $B%M%C%H%o!<%/$O!"%"%/%F%#%V$Ju(B ry $B;HMQ$7$^$9!#$=$7$F!"$=$l$i$,uFM5/$r%K%e!<%m%s$,;}$C$F$$$k$N$O2?8N$+!"$H$$$&M}O@$r7g$$$F$$$k!"%G%#!<%W%i!<%K%s%0!J(BLeCun et al$B!#!"(B2015$B!K$d%9%Q%$%-%s%0%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/!J(BMaass$B!"(B1997$B!K$G;H$o$l$F$$$kMM$J$[$H$s$I$9$Y$F$N?M9)%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/$,!"%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$N$J$$!"$=$7$FHs8=/$J$$%7%J%W%9$N$"$k?M9)%K%e!<%m%s$r;HMQ$7$F$$$k;v$O!"u(B ry $B$rM}2r(B ry $B!#(B
$B?7Hi$9$k$N$G$"$l$P!"@8J*3XE*%K%e!<%m%s$,$=$l$i$N%7%J%W%9?t@i8D5Z$S%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$r$I$N$h$&$K;HMQ$9$k$+$r2f!9$OM}2r$9$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"%K%e!<%m%s$OC1FH$G$OM}2r(B ry $B!#(B
$B$b$A$m$s!"%K%e!<%m%s72$O3VN%$7$F$"$C$F$OM}2r$G$-$^$;$s!#(B
? $B$=$l$>$l2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$D%K%e!<%m%s$N%M%C%H%o!<%/$,6&DL$NL\E*$K8~$+$C$F$I$N$h$&$K6(D4$7$F5!G=$9$k$N$+$H$$$&Jd40E*$JM}O@$bI,MW$G$9!#(B
$B2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$r3F!9H<$&%K%e!<%m%s$N!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$,$I$NMM$K$7$F6&DL$NL\E*$K8~$+$C$F6&$K5!G=$9$k$N$+$H$$$&Jd40E*$JM}O@$r$b2f!9$OI,MW$H$7$^$9!#(B

$BK\9F$G$O$=$N$h$&$JM}O@$r>R2p$7$^$9!#(B
? $B:G=i$K!"2f!9$O!"3h@-$JuFM5/$H2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$D(B ry $B$,!"2?I4$H$$$&FHFC$N%Q%?!<%s$N:YK&3h@-$rG'<1$G$-$k$3$H$r<((B ry $B!#(B
$B:G=i$K!"%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$H!"2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$H!"$r;}$DE57?E*$J?mBN%K%e!<%m%s$,!":YK&%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$N2?I4$H$$$&%f%K!<%/%Q%?!<%s$r$I$NMM$K$7$FG'<1$G$-$k$+!"$r2f!9$O<($7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B2f!9$O!"A4BN(B ry $B$,$^$P$i$G$"$k8B$j%K%e!<%m%s$,BgNL(B ry $B2<$G$b?tI4(B ry $B$rG'<1$G$-$k$3$H$r<($9!#(B
$BA4BNE*$J?@7P3h@-$,AB$G$"$k8B$j!"BgNL$N%N%$%:$*$h$SJQF0@-$NB8:_2<$G$b!"?tI4$N%Q%?!<%s$r%K%e!<%m%s$,G'<1$G$-$k!";v$r2f!9$O<($9!#(B
$BuLZ$N$5$^$6$^$JItJ,$X$NF~NO$,$5$^$6$^$JL\E*$KLrN)$D%K%e!<%m%s%b%G%k$r>R2p$7$^$9!#(B
$B$3$N%b%G%k$G$O!"%K%e!<%m%s$N1s0L%7%J%W%9$K$h$C$FG'<1$5$l$k%Q%?!<%s$,M=B,$K;HMQ$5$l$^$9!#(B
? $B3F%K%e!<%m%s$O!":YK&$,3hF0E*$K$J$kA0$K$7$P$7$P5/$3$k2?I4$b$N%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$3$H$r3X(B ry $B!#(B
$B:YK&$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$k$h$j$b!"$7$P$7$P@h9T$9$k2?I4$b$N%Q%?!<%s!"$rG'<1$9$k;v$r3F%K%e!<%m%s$O3X$S$^$9!#(B
? ry $B3X=,%Q%?!<%s(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N3X=,:Q%Q%?!<%s$N$$$:$l$+$rG'<1$9$k$3$H$O!"3hF0EE0L$rD>@\0z$-5/$3$9$3$H$J$/:YK&$rC&J,6K$9$k$3$H$K$h$kM=B,$H$7$F:nMQ$9$k!#(B
$B:G8e$K!"$3$N@-$N%K%e!<%m%s$rM^@)$9$k$3$H$K0MB8$7$F$$$k$?$a!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$N3h@-2=$,M=B,$KJP$C$F$$$^$9!#(B
$BC&J,6K%K%e!<%m%s$,?WB.H/2P$7$FB>$N6aK5%K%e!<%m%s$rM^@)$9$k!";v$K%M%C%H%o!<%/%b%G%k$,0MB8$7$F$*$j!"=>$C$F!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$N%"%/%F%#%Y!<%7%g%s$r$=$l$NM=B,$NJ}$X%P%$%"%9$7$^$9!#(B
$B%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$rDL$8$F!"%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j%M%C%H%o!<%/$,%*%s%i%$%s3X=,!"J#?tF1;~M=B,!"$*$h$S7xO4@-$J$I$NB??t$NK>$^$7$$FC@-$r<($9$3$H$r@bL@$7$^$9!#(B

? ry $B?dO@$H9TF0$N$?$a(B ry $B=EMW@-$r9M$($k$H!"(B $B2f!9$O!"%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j$,(B ry $BFC@-$G$"$j!"$7$?$,$C$F(B ry $BI=$9$3$H$rDs0F$9$k!#(B
$B?7Hi$C$F?7Hie$NC10l%Q%?!<%s$N3hF0$rG'<1$9$k$H9M$($k$N$,0lHLE*$G$9!#(B
$B0lHL>o<1E*$K9M$($i$l$F$$$kC10l%K%e!<%m%s$H$7$F$O!"$=$l$N%7%J%W%9$K1w$1$k%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$NC10l%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$7$^$9!#(B
? $B!V35G0%K%e!<%m%s!W(B ry $B!#(B
$B!V%]%$%s%H%K%e!<%m%s!W$H8F$P$l$k$3$H$b$"$k$3$N35G0$O!"$[$H$s$I$9$Y$F$N?M9)%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/$N4pAC$r7A@.$7$F$$$^$9!J?^(B1A$B!K!#(B

[$B?^(B1$B$3$3$K$D$$$F869F$N=*$o$j$r8+$k(B]

? $B3hF0E*uFM5/$O!"%K%e!<%m%s$NB?$/$NFHFC$J%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k%K%e!<%m%s$N0[$J$k8+2r$r<(:6$7$F$$$k!J(B ry $B!#(B
$B%f%K!<%/%Q%?!<%sB??t$r%K%e!<%m%s72$OG'<1$9$k$,$=$3$K1w$F!"%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$O$=$N%K%e!<%m%s$N0[$J$k8+2r$r<(:6$9$k!J(BLarkum and Nevian$B!"(B2008; Poirazi et al$B!#!"(B2003; Polsky et al$B!#!"(B2004$B!K!#(B
$BuFM5/>e$N6u4VE*$K6a@\$7$?(B8-20$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$NF1;~3h@-2=$,Hs@~7AE*$K7k9g$7!"(BNMDA$BuFM5/%9%Q%$%/$r0z$-5/$3$9$3$H$r<($7$F$$$k(B $B!J(BLarkum et al$B!#!"(B1999; Major et al$B!#!"(B2013; Schiller and Schiller$B!"(B2001; Schiller et al$B!#!"(B2000$B!K!#(B
? ry $B$7$?$,$C$F!">/?t$NNY@\%7%J%W%9$,%Q%?!<%s(B ry $B!#(B
$B=>$C$F!"6aNY%7%J%W%9$N>.%;%C%H$,%Q%?!<%s8!=P4o$H$7$F5!G=$7$^$9!#(B
? $B$=$N7k2L!":YK&(B ry $BFM5/>e(B ry $B%7%J%W%9$,0lO"$NFHN)$7$?%Q%?!<%s8!=P4o$H$7$F5!G=$9$k$3$H$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
$B$=$l$O!":YK&$NuFM5/$N>e$N2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$,FHN)%Q%?!<%s8!=P4o$N%;%C%H$H$7$F3hF0$9$k;v!"$r;Y1g$7$^$9!#(B


2


? ry $B8!=P$5$l$k$H!"BN:YK&$K(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$H$=$l$KB3$/C&J,6K$,5/$3$j$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N%Q%?!<%s$N$$$:$l$+$N8!=P$O!"(B NMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$H$=$l$KB3$/C&J,6K$r:YK&BN$K1w$F5/$3$7$^$9!#(B

? 8^Z20$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$,!"BgNL$N:YK&$N3hF0%Q%?!<%s$r3N$_$^$9!#(B
$B%K%e!<%m%s$NuFM5/$N%;%/%7%g%s$,(B2,000$B8D$N%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$N$&$A$N$o$:$+(B10$B8D$K?7$7$$%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$7!"(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$r@8@.$9$k$?$a$N$7$-$$CM$,(B10$B$G$"$k>l9g!"(B10$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$9$Y$F$,F1;~$K3h@-2=$ruFM5/$O%?!<%2%C%H%Q%?!<%s$r8!=P$7$^$9!#(B
$BuFM5/$O!"F1$8(B10$B8D$N%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$r6&M-$9$kB>$NB?$/$N%Q%?!<%s$r8m$C$F8!=P$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$3$H$KCm0U$7$F$/$@$5$$!#(B
? ry $B>l9g!"(B10$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$,0[$J$k(B ry $B%"%/%F%#%V(B ry $B!#(B
$B$7$+$7!"%Q%?!<%s$,$^$P$i$G$"$k>l9g!"0[$J$k%i%s%@%`%Q%?!<%s$KBP$7$F(B 10 $B%7%J%W%9$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$k2DG=@-$O$o$:$+$G$9!#(B
? ry $B$G$O(B9.8 ry $B!#(B
$B$3$NNc$G$O6O$+(B 9.8 x 10 ^ -21$B$G$9!#(B

$B8m$C$?0lCW$N3NN($O!"l9g!"M?$($i$l$?;~E@$G$N%;%k(B ry n$B!"$=$N=8CDFb$N%"%/%F%#%V(B ry $B!#(B
$B%9%Q!<%9%Q%?!<%s(Ba$B"c(B n$B$N>l9g!"%;%k=8CD$N%5%$%:$r(Bn$B!"$=$N=8CDFb$NM?$($i$l$?;~E@$G$N%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$N?t$r(Ba$B$H$7$^$9!#(B
$BuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H>e$N%7%J%W%9$N?t$r#s$H$7!"#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/ogCM$r&H$H$9$k!#(B
? $B>/$J$/$H$b&H8D$N%7%J%W%9$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$k>l9g!"$9$J$o$A>/$J$/$H$b&H8D$N%7%J%W%9$,8=:_%"%/%F%#%V$J%;%k$H0lCW$9$k>l9g!"%;%0%a%s%H$O%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$H8@(B ry $B!#(B
$B%7%J%W%9>/$J$/$H$b&H8D$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$k>l9gB($A!"%7%J%W%9>/$J$/$H$b&H8D$H8=%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$H$,0lCW$9$k>l9g!"%Q%?!<%s$r%;%0%a%s%H$,G'<1$9$k$H2f!9$O8@$$$^$9!#(B

? ry $B$^$9!#(B
$B%Q%?!<%s$N%i%s%@%`$JJ,I[$r2>Dj$9$k$H!"8m$C$?0lCW$N@53N$J3NN($O^Z ^Z^Z^Z $B%i(B ^Z ^Z^Z^Z ^Z ^Z

$B!J(B1$B!K(B  http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#3


$BJ,Jl$O!"C1=c$K#N8D$NA4:YK&$N=8CDCf$N#a8D$N3h@-:YK&$r4^$`2DG=$J%Q%?!<%s$NAm?t$G$"$k!#(B
$BJ,;R$O!"(B1$B$D$Nu%;%0%a%s%H>e$N&H8D0J>e$N%7%J%W%9$K@\B3$9$k%Q%?!<%s$N?t$r?t$($^$9!#(B
? ry $B$N>\:Y(B ry 2015$B!K$K$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B$3$NJ}Dx<0$N$h$j>\:Y$J@bL@$O!J(BAhmad and Hawkins$B!"(B2015$B!KFb$G8+IU$1$k;v$,$G$-$^$9!#(B

? $B$3$N<0$O!"Hs@~7Au%;%0%a%s%H$,%5%V(B ry $B%Q%?!<%sFb$N>/?t$N%;%k$@$1(B ry $B%m%P%9%H$KJ,N`(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$N<0$O!"%5%V%5%s%W%j%s%0!JJ,N`$5$l$k$Y$-%Q%?!<%s!"$NCf$N>/?t$N%;%k!"$@$1$K%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k$3$H!K$K$h$C$F%Q%?!<%s$r%m%P%9%H$KHs@~7Au%;%0%a%s%H$,J,N`$G$-$k$3$H$r<($7$F$$$k!#(B
S1 Text$B$NI=(BA$B$O!"<0!J(B1$B!K$+$i7W;;$5$l$?BeI=E*$J8m$jN($r<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B

NMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$r@8@.$9$k$N$KI,MW$J?t$h$j$bB?$/$N%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"G'<1$O%N%$%:$HJQF0$KBP$7$F4h6/$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $BI,MW$J(B2$BG\$N%7%J%W%9$r(B20$B8D7A@.$9$k$H!"(B50$B!s$N%;%k$,JQ99$5$l$F$bu(B ry $B$G$-$^$9!#$^$?$OHs%"%/%F%#%V(B
$B$?$H$($P!"uFM5/$N(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$7$-$$CM$,(B10$B$G!"G'<1$7$?$$%Q%?!<%s$KI,MW$J%7%J%W%9$N(B 2 $BG\$?$k(B 20 $B8D$r7A@.$9$k$H!"Nc$((B 50 % $B$N%;%k$,$b$7JQ99$5$l$k$+Kt$OHs%"%/%F%#%V$G$"$k$+!"$N>l9g$G$"$l$I$buFM5/$O%?!<%2%C%H%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$G$-$^$9!#(B
? ry a false positive error.
$BM>J,$J%7%J%W%9$O$^$?8m8!CN%(%i!<$N2DG=@-$r9b$a$^$9!#(B
? $B%(%i!<$N2DG=@-$O9b$^$j$^$7$?$,!"<0!J(B1$B!K$O!"%Q%?!<%s$,$^$P$i$G$"$k$H$-$K$O$^$@>.$5$$$3$H$r<((B ry $B!#(B
$B%Q%?!<%s$,AB$G$"$k;~$K$O!"%(%i!<$N2DG=@-$,A}Bg$7$h$&$H$b$=$l$O$^$@:3:Y!"$G$"$k$H<0!J(B1$B!K$O<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B
? ry 2$BG\$K$7$F(B50 ry $B!#(B
$B>e5-$NNc$G$O!"%7%J%W%9$N?t$r(B2$BG\$K$7$=$l8N(B50$B!s$J%N%$%:5vMFEY$rF3F~$9$k$H!"%(%i!<$N2DG=@-$O$o$:$+(B1.6 x 10 ^ -18$B$^$GA}2C$7$^$9!#(B
S1$B%F%-%9%H$NI=(B1B$B$K!"%7%J%W%9?t$,$7$-$$CM$rD6$($?$H$-$NBeI=E*$J%(%i!u%;%0%a%s%H>e$K6&B8$9$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B$=$l$i$,8_$$$N(B40$B&L(Bm$B0JFb$K$"$k>l9g!"(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$r@8@.$9$k$N$K$o$:$+(B8$B$D$N%7%J%W%9$G==J,$G$9!J(BMajor et al$B!#!"(B2008$B!K!#(B
$B%7%J%W%9$,uFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$K1h$C$F9-$,$C$F$$$k>l9g!":GBg(B20$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$,I,MW$H$5$l$k!J(BMajor et al$B!#!"(B2013$B!K!#(B
$Bu%;%0%a%s%H$K$O?tI4$N%7%J%W%9$r4^$a$k$3$H$,$G$-$^$9!#(B $B$7$?$,$C$F!"3F%;%0%a%s%H$OJ#?t$N%Q%?!<%s$r8!=P$G$-$^$9!#(B
? $B0[$J$k%Q%?!<%s(B ry $B$,u(B ry $B>e$G0l=o$K:.9g$5$l$F$$$k>l9g!"0[$J$k%Q%?!<%s$+$i$N%7%J%W%9$rF1;~3h@-2=$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F%(%i!<$N$5$i$J$k2DG=@-$r$b$?$i$9!#(B
$B0[%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k%7%J%W%9$,$b$7$b0l=o$Ku%;%0%a%s%H>e$G:.8r$5$l$F$$$k$J$i$P!"0[%Q%?!<%sM3Mh$J%7%J%W%9F1;~3h@-2=$K$h$k99$J$k8m$j2DG=@-$r>7$/!#(B
? ry $B$HG'<1$5$l$k%Q%?!<%s$N4uGv$5$K$h$C$F0[$J$j$^$9!#(B
$B$3$N%?%$%W$N%(%i!<$N2DG=@-$O!"uFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$r6&M-$9$k%7%J%W%9%;%C%H$N?t$HHoG'<1%Q%?!<%sAB@-$H!"$K0MB8$7$^$9!#(B
? $B9-$$HO0O$NCM$KBP$7$F!"(B ry $B!#(B
$B9-HO0O$NCM$KBP$7$F$N!"$3$N/@53N(B ry $B$K$O(B40 ry $B!"$d$dIT@53N(B ry $B$H:.9g$9$k(B ry $B!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"FCDj$N%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$?$a$N%7%J%W%9$NG[CV$O4vJ,@53N$G$9!J$=$l$i$OF1$8u%;%0%a%s%H>e$K$"$j!"M}A[E*$K$OAj8_$K(B40$B&L(Bm$B0JFb$K$"$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!K$,!"4vJ,IT@53N$G$b$"$j$^$9!JB>$N%7%J%W%9$H:.8r$9$k$H%(%i!<$r5/$3$7$K$/$$!K!#(B

? ry $B$9$k$?$a$KJ?6Q(B ry $B3d$jEv$F$i$l!"%K%e!<%m%s$,(B6,000$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$D$H2>Dj$9$k$H!":YK&$OLs(B300$B8D$N0[$J$k%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1(B ry $B!#(B
$B3F%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k0Y$NJ?6Q(B20$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$,3dEv$F$i$l!"$=$7$F$=$N%K%e!<%m%s$O%7%J%W%9$r(B 6000 $B8D;}$D!"$H2>Dj$9$k$H!"Ls(B300$B8D$N0[%Q%?!<%s$r:YK&$OG'<1$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$^$9!#(B
? $B$3$l$O$*$*$h$=$N35;;(B ry $B$O!"B??t$N:YK&Fb$G2?I4$b$N%Q%?!<%s$r3NuFM5/$r;}$D%K%e!<%m%s$O!"2?I4$b$N%Q%?!<%s$r3NuFM5/$rM-$9$k$N$G!"3F6=J3@-?7Hi@\$D$J$,$k$N$G$O$J$/Be$o$j$K!"%K%e!<%m%s$N%M%C%H%o!<%/$,M=B,$r9T$C$F%7!<%1%s%9$r3X=,$9$kLr3d$r$I$NMM$K2L$?$9$+$rDs0F$7$^$9!#(B

? ry 3$B$D$N8;(B
$B#2!%#1!%#1!#(B $BHiuLZ$N0[$J$kItJ,$KJ,N%$5$l$F$$$k$5$^$6$^$J%=!<%9$+$i6=J3@-F~NO$r!<%s$KJ,$1$F<($7$^$9!#(B
? $B6a0L%>!<%s(B ry $B!#(B
$B6a0L(B ( $B!<%s$O%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$r!<%s$OJ8L.E*F~NO$NBgItJ,$r!"F1$8Hiu@1:YK&$G$9!#(B ry $B$+$i@hC<$NuFM5/(B ry $B9M$($i$l$^$9!#!K(B
$B@mC<%>!<%s$O%U%#!<%I%P%C%/F~NO$ru:YK&$G$9!#?mBN:YK&$+$i@mC<uFM5/$r=|$$$?$b$N$K;w$F$$$k$H9M$($i$l$k$H2f!9$O%5%8%'%9%H$7$^$9!#!K(B
$B2f!9$O!"%K%e!<%m%s>e$N%7%J%W%9E}9g$N#3$D$N%>!<%s!J6a0L!"4pDl!"$*$h$SD:Cu(B ry $B%7%J%W%9$O!"BN:YK&$KHf3SE*(B ry $B!#(B
$BuFM5/!JE57?E*$K$O?tI4!K>e$N%7%J%W%9$O!":YK&BN$K1w$F$NHf3SE*Bg$-$J1F6A$r5Z$\$7!"$7$?$,$C$F!"%K%e!<%m%s$N4pK\E*$Jl9g!"$*$h$S6a0L%7%J%W%9$X$NF~NO$,$b$7$b%9%Q!<%9E*%"%/%F%#%V$G$"$k>l9g!"(B $B6a0L%7%J%W%9$O!"@h$KO@$8$?$N$HF1$8J}K!$GJ#?t$N8GM-$N%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%I%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k!#(B
? ry $B$NOB=89g$H$7$F(B ry $B!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!":YK&$N%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IuFM5/$,G'<1$9$k;v$rDs0F!"$3$NJ}K!$G4pDluFM5/$O%"%/%F%#%S%F%#%Q%?!<%s4V$NA+0\$r3X=,$75-21$9$k!#(B
$B4pDluFM5/>e$G%Q%?!<%s$,G'<1$5$l$k$H!"(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$,H/@8$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B%9%Q%$%/$K$h$kC&J,6K$OBN:YK&$KE~C#$9$k$^$G$K?6I}$,8:?j$9$k$?$a!"4pDluFM5/$,%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$HBN:YK&(B ry $B$9$k$,BN:YK&3hF0EE0L$r@8@.(B  ry $B$K==J,$G$O$J$$(B ry $B!K!#(B
NMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$=$lC10l$G$NC&J,6K$K1w$F$O$=$l$,:YK&BNE~C#$^$G$K;~4V$H6&$K?6I}8:?j$=$N0Y!"%Q%?!<%sG'<1;~$K1w$F4pDluFM5/$O!":YK&BN$rC&J,6K$9$k$,:YK&BN3hF0EE0L@8@.$K$OIT=C$,(B ry $B!#(B
$B2f!9$O!"$3$NogCM2uBV$G$"$k$3$H$rDs0F$9$k!#(B
$B$3$l$O!"%;%k$,$^$b$J$/%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$NF0:n$K=EMW$JLr3d$r2L$?$9$H$$$&M=B,$rI=$7$F$$$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"$=$N8e==J,$J(B ry $B!#(B
$B$o$:$+$KC&J,6K$7$?:YK&$O!"$=$&$G$J$$>l9g$K=l9g$h$j$bAa$/H/2P$7$^$9!#(B
? $BAa$/H/o$K$^$P$i$J3hF0%Q%?!<%s(B ry $B!#(B
$BAa$/H/2P$9$k$3$H$K$h$j!"$=$l$O6aNY$N%;%k$rM^@)$7!"@5$7$/M=B,$5$l$?F~NOC#$X$HJs$$$?2aAB%"%/%F%#%V%Q%?!<%s$r:n$j=P$9!#(B
? ry $B$D$$$F$O!"8e$G>\$7$/@bL@$7$^$9!#(B
$B$3$N%a%+%K%:%`$K$D$$$F!"8e$N%;%/%7%g%s$NCf$G2f!9$O>\$7$/@bL@$7$^$9!#(B

? $BD:C<%7%J%W%9(B ry $B4|BT$r(B ry
$B@mC<%7%J%W%9$O%H%C%W%@%&%s$N4|BT(B ( $BLuCm(B : $BBTK>(B $BM=A[(B ) $B$r8F$S5/$3$9(B

$B%K%e!<%m%s$N@hC<uFM5/$b$^$?!"%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$H(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$r@8@.$7$^$9!J(BCichon and Gan$B!"(B2015$B!K!#(B
$BD:C<(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$O!"BN:YK&$KD>@\1F6A$rM?$($^$;$s!#(B
? $B$=$NBe$o$j$K!"(B ry $B$r0z$-5/$3$92DG=@-$,$"$k!J(B ry $B!#(B
$B$=$NBe$o$j!"$=$l$O@hC<uFM5/$K$*$1$k(BCa 2+$B%9%Q%$%/$rM6H/$9$k;v$,$G$-$k!J(BGolding et al$B!#!"(B1999; Larkum et al$B!#!"(B2009$B!K!#(B
$BC10l$ND:C<#C#a(B $B#2!\%9%Q%$%/$OBN:YK&$rC&J,6K$9$k$,!"E57?E*$K$OBN:YK&3hF0EE0L$r@8@.$9$k$N$K==J,$G$O$J$$!J#A#n#t#i#c$i!"#2#0#1#0!K!#(B
? $BD:C<$N(BCa 2+$B%9%Q%$%/!"4pAC(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/!"$*$h$SBN$N3hF0EE0L$N4V$NAj8_:nMQ$O!"?J9T(B ry $B>r7o2<(B ry $B!"D:C<u(B ry $B!#(B
$B@mC<(B Ca 2+ $B%9%Q%$%/$H!"4pDl(B NMDA $B%9%Q%$%/$H!":YK&BN3hF0EE0L$H!"$N4V$N%$%s%?%i%/%7%g%s$O!"?J9TCf$N8&5f$NJ,Ln$G$9!J(BLarkum$B!"(B2013$B!K(B $B!#(B $B$7$+$7!"B?$/$N>r7o$N2<$G!"@mC<uFM5/>e$NG'<1$5$l$?%Q%?!<%s$O:YK&$rC&J,6K$7!"$7$?$,$C$F4pDluFM5/>e$NG'<1$5$l$?%Q%?!<%s$HF1MM$N8z2L$rM-$9$k$H8@$($k!#(B
$B2f!9$O!"D:C<uFM5/$K$h$C$F0z$-5/$3$5$l$kC&J,6K$,%H%C%W%@%&%s4|BTCM$r3NN)$9$k$?$a$K;HMQ$5$l$k$3$H$rDs0F$9$k!#$3$l$OJL$NM=B,7ABV$H$7$F9M$($k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B

$B#2!%#1!%#2!#(B HTM$B%b%G%k%K%e!<%m%s(B

$B?^#1#C$O!"2f!9$,2f!9$N%=%U%H%&%'%"%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$G;HMQ$9$k?mBN%K%e!<%m%s$NCj>]E*$J%b%G%k$r<($9!#(B
$B%;%k$NuFM5/$r$7$-$$CM0lCW8!=P4o$N%;%C%H$H$7$F%b%G%k2=$7$^$9!#(B $B$=$l$>$l$KFH<+$N%7%J%W%9$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
 $BuFM5/!?0lCW8!=P4o>e$N%"%/%F%#%V$J%7%J%W%9$N?t$,$7$-$$CM$rD6$($k$H!"%;%k$O%Q%?!<%s$r8!=P$9$k!#(B

$B0lCW8!=P4o$O!"?mBN:YK&$N6a0LuFM5/!"4pDluFM5/!"$*$h$SD:C<uFM5/$KBP1~$9$k(B3$B$D$N%0%k!<%W$KJ,$1$i$l$k!#(B
? ry $B$*$h$SE@>u%K%e!<%m%s(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$N%b%G%k%K%e!<%m%s$r@8J*3XE*%K%e!<%m%s5Z$S%]%$%s%H%K%e!<%m%s$H6hJL$9$k$?$a$K!V(BHTM$B%K%e!<%m%s!W$H8F$S$^$9!#(B
HTM$B$O(BHierarchical Temporal Memory$B$NN,8l$G!";d$?$A$N?7HiuFM5/(B/$B0lCW8!=P4o$r;}(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$NO@J8$N%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$G;HMQ$7$?(BHTM$B%K%e!<%m%s$O!"uFM5/$"$?$j(B 40 $B0J2<8D$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$D(B128$B8D$N!"uFM5/(B/$B0lCW8!=P4o!"$r;}$C$F$$$^$9!#(B
$BL@3N$K$9$k$?$a$K!"?^#1#C$O$o$:$+$JuFM5/$*$h$S%7%J%W%9$N$_$r<($9!#(B

2.2$B!#(B $B%K%e!<%m%s$N%M%C%H%o!<%/$O%7!<%1%s%9$r3X$V(B

? $B?7Hiu(B ry $B%K%e!<%m%s$G9=@.$5$l$F$$$k$N$G!"$=$l$O?7HiuFM5/$H2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$H$r;}$D%K%e!<%m%s$G?7Hi@8M}3X$N:G$b=EMW$G:G$bL5;k$5$l$F$$$kLdBj!W$HM-L>$K8F$s$G$$$?$b$N$G$9(B $B!J(BLashley$B!"(B1951$BG/!K!#(B
? ry $B:YK&AX$,6&DL$NG[Ns5-21%"%k%4%j%:%`$NJQ7A7ABV$r\:Y$K$*$$$F0[$J$kM}M3$G$"$k!#(B
? $BK\9F$G$O!"$=$N%P%j%(!<%7%g%s$r>\$7$/@bL@$;$:$K!"4pK\E*$J%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j%"%k%4%j%:%`$G$"$k$H9M$($F$$$k$3$H$r@bL@$7$^$9!#(B
$BK\9F$G2f!9$O!"2f!9$,?.$8$k4pK\E*%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j%"%k%4%j%:%`$r!"$=$N%P%j%(!<%7%g%s$N:YeL$K$^$GN)F~$i$:$K!"<($7$^$9!#(B

$B2f!9$O!"?7Hil9g!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$O?7$7$$F~NO$4$H$K=y!9$K$=$7$F7QB3E*$KE,1~$9$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
2$B!K(B $B9bpJs$rl9g!"%*!<%P%i%C%W$7$?J,4t%7!<%1%s%9$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j$OF1;~$KJ#?t$NM=B,$r9T$&I,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
? 4$B!K(B $BCO0h3X=,(B ry
4$B!K(B $B%m!<%+%k3X=,%k!<%k(B
? $B%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j$O!"3F%K%e!<%m%s$K%m!<%+%k$J3X=,5,B'$N$_$r;HMQ$9$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B%7!<%1%s%95-21$,;HMQ$9$k3X=,5,B'$O3F%K%e!<%m%s$K%m!<%+%k$J$b$N$@$1$G$J$1$l$P$J$j$^$;$s!#(B
? $B%0%m!<%P%k$JL\E*4X?t$rI,MW$H(B ry $B!#(B
$B%0%m!<%P%k%*%V%8%'%/%HE*4X?t$rI,MW$H$;$:$K!"5,B'$O6u4VE*$K$b;~4VE*$K$b6I=jE*$G$J$1$l$P$J$j$^$;$s!#(B
5$B!K(B $B7xO4@-(B
$B%a%b%j$O!"9b%l%Y%k$N%N%$%:!"%K%e!<%m%s$NB;<:!"$*$h$SF~NO$N<+A3$JJQF0$KBP$9$k7xO4@-$r<($9$O$:$G$9!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N>r7o2<$G$N%Q%U%)!<%^%s%9$NDc2<$O4K$d$+$K$J$k$O$:$G$9!#(B

$B$3$l$i$9$Y$F$N%W%m%Q%F%#$O!"%G!<%?$rO"B3E*$K%9%H%j!<%_%s%0$9$k$H$$$&>u67$GF1;~$KH/@8$9$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B


4


$B#2!%#2!%#1!#(B $B%_%K%3%i%`$H%K%e!<%m%s!'(B2$B$D$NI=8=(B

$B9bJ}$OFCDj$N;~4VE*J8L.$K$*$1$k%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$rI=$9!#(B
? ry $B=8CD$K$*$1$k3h@-2=$N$^$P$i$J%Q%?!<%s(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$NMW7o$r@bL@$9$k$?$a$K!"(B2$B$D$NCj>]%7!<%1%s%9!V(BABCD$B!W$H!V(BXBCY$B!W$r8!F$$7$^$9!#3FJ8;z$O!"%K%e!<%m%s$NJl=8CD$NCf$N%"%/%F%#%Y!<%7%g%s$N%9%Q!<%9%Q%?!<%s$rI=$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$,3X=,(B ry $B!W$H6&$KDs<((B ry $B!W$H6&$KDs<((B ry $B!#(B 
$B$3$l$i$N%7!<%1%s%9$,0lC63X=,$5$l$k$H!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$O!"%7!<%1%s%9!V#A#B#C!W$rDs<($5$l$?$H$-$K!V#D!W$rM=B,$7!"%7!<%1%s%9!V#X#B#C!W$rDs<($5$l$?$H$-$K!V#Y!W$rM=B,$9$k$O$:$G$"$k!#(B 
? $B$7$?$,$C$F!"%5%V(B ry $B!W$N4V$NFbItI=8=$O!"(B2$B$D$N>l9g$G0[$J$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B  $B$=$&$G$J$$$H!"!V(BC$B!W$,I=<($5$l$?8e$K@5$7$$M=B,$r9T$&$3$H$,(B ry $B!#(B
$B=>$C$F!"$=$N(B 2 $B$D$N>l9g$K1w$F$N$=$l$i%5%V%7!<%1%s%9!V(BBC$B!W$N4V$N$=$l$iFbItI=8=$O0[$J$i$M$P$J$i$J$$!#(B  $B$5$b$J$/$P!V(BC$B!WDs<(8e$K!"@5$7$$M=B,$r@.$9;v$,$G$-$^$;$s!#(B

? ry $B:YK&AX$K$I$N$h$&$KI=$l$F$$$k$+$r<($7$F$$$k$3$H$r<((B ry $B!#(B
$B?^(B2$B$O!"$3$l$i(B2$B$D$NI=8=$,HiH(B ry ) 
$B%M%C%H%o!<%/$X$N3F%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$O!"%"%/%F%#%V%_%K%+%i%`$N%9%Q!<%9%;%C%H$KJQ49$5$l$^$9!#(B ( $B?7HiH$7$F$$$^$9!#(B ) 
$B%_%K%+%i%`Fb$N$9$Y$F$N%K%e!<%m%s$O!"F1$8%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IC$5$l$k$3$H$K$J$k!#(B
$B$7$+$7$J$,$i!"0JA0$K3X=,$5$l$?%7!<%1%s%9$NJ8L.$G$O!"%_%K%+%i%`Fb$N%;%k$N$&$A$N#1$D$^$?$OJ#?t$OC&J,6K$9$k;v$K$J$k!#(B
? ry $B$rAK32$7$^$9!#(B
$BC&J,6K:YK&$O3hF0EE0L$r@8@.$9$k:G=i$N:YK&$K$J$j!"6a$/$NB>$N:YK&$rM^@)$7$^$9!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"M=B,$5$l$?F~NO$O!"FCDj$N0LCV$K$*$$$F!"FCDj$N=g=x$G!"FCDj$NMWAG$K8GM-$NHs>o$K$^$P$i$J%Q%?!<%s$N:YK&3h@-2=$r$b$?$i$9!#(B

[$B$3$3$N?^(B2$B869F$N=*$o$j$r8+$k(B]

? $B#2!%#2!%#2!#(B $B4pAC(B ry 
$B#2!%#2!%#2!#(B $B4pDl%7%J%W%9$O%7!<%1%s%95-21$N4pAC$G$"$k(B

$B$3$NM}O@$G$O!":YK&$O$=$l$i$N4pDl%7%J%W%9$r;H$C$FF~NO%Q%?!<%s4V$NA+0\$r3X=,$7$^$9!#(B
$B?7$?$J%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$N$?$S$K!"$$$/$D$+$N:YK&$O$=$l$i$N6a0L%7%J%W%9$r2p$7$F3h@-$K$J$k!#(B
? ry $B$=$7$F:F$S%Q%?!<%s$r8+$k$H!"C&J,6K$7!"$=$l$K$h$C$F$N:YK&$O!"$=$l$i$N4pDl%7%J%W%9$r;HMQ$7$F!"$3$N3h@-%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$3$H$r3X$S!"$=$7$F$=$N%Q%?!<%s$r:F$S8+$k$H!"C&J,6K$7$=$l$K$h$C$F!"J}$r<($7$F$*$j!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$O0JA0$K3X=,$7$?%7!<%1%s%9$K=>$&!#(B

[$B$3$3$N?^(B3$B869F$N=*$o$j$r8+$k(B]

$BB?$/$N>l9g!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$OJ#?t$NF1;~M=B,$r9T$$$^$9!#(B
$BNc$($P!"%7!<%1%s%9!V(BABCD$B!W$H!V(BXBCY$B!W$r3X=,$7$?8e!"%7%9%F%`$r$"$$$^$$$J%5%V%7!<%1%s%9!V(BBC$B!W$@$1$K$5$i$9$H$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"%7%9%F%`$K!V(BD$B!W$H!V(BY$B!W$NN>J}$rF1;~$KM=B,$5$;$^$9!#(B
$B$3$N>l9g!"!V(BD$B!W$H!V(BY$B!W$H$NN>J}$rF1;~$K%7%9%F%`$,M=B,$9$k;v$r2f!9$OM_$9$k!#(B
$B?^#3#B$O!"F~NO$,$"$$$^$$$J$H$-$K%M%C%H%o!<%/$,$I$N$h$&$K$7$FJ#?t$NM=B,$r9T$&$+$r<($9!#(B
? $B8m$j$N2DG=@-$,Dc$$$H$-$K9T$&$3$H$,$G$-$kF1;~(B ry $B!#(B
$B8m$j2DG=@->.$J$^$^@.$;$kF1;~M=B,$N?t$b!"<0!J#1!K$K$h$C$F7W;;$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B
$BM=B,$OHs>o$K$^$P$i$G$"$k798~$,$"$k$N$G!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$,:.Mp$9$k$3$H$J$/F1;~$K2?==$b$N%Q%?!<%s$rM=B,$9$k$3$H$O2DG=$G$9!#(B
? ry $B@5$7$$%9%Q!<%9I=8=(B ry $B!#(B
$BF~NO$,$$$:$l$+$NM=B,$K0lCW$9$k$H!"@5$7$$2aABI=8=$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $B>l9g!"NsFb$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k(B ry $B$J$j!"M=4|$7$J$$F~NO$r<((B  ry $B!#(B
$BF~NO$,$I$NM=B,$K$b0lCW$7$J$$>l9g!"%+%i%`Fb$NA4%;%k$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j!"M=4|$;$LF~NO$G$"$k$H<($7$^$9!#(B

? $B%_%K%3%i%`Fb(B ry $B$N4pK\%7%J%W%9(B ry $B!#(B
$B%_%K%+%i%`Fb$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$OF1$8%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%I1~Ez$r6&M-$7$^$9$,!"$=$l$i$N4pDl%7%J%W%9$O0[$J$k%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"%_%K%3%i%`Fb(B ry $B%l%Y%k$,Dc$/$J$j$^$9!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"%_%K%+%i%`Fb$N%;%k$O!"3X=,$5$l$?0[$J$k0l;~E*$J%3%s%F%-%9%H$G0l0U$K1~Ez$7!"F~NO$,M=A[$5$l$k>l9g$OA4BNE*%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$N%l%Y%k$,AB$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$i$NB0@-$ON>J}$H$b4Q;!$5$l$F$$$k!J(BMartin and Schr er$B!"(B2013; Vinje and Gallant$B!"(B2002; Yen et al$B!#!"(B2007$B!K!#(B

$B?^#3#A$N:G8e$N%Q%M%k$N%;%k$N$&$A$N#1$D$K$D$$$F!"%;%k$,M=B,$r9T$&$?$a$K;HMQ$7$?#3$D$N@\B3$r<($9!#(B
? ry $B!":YK&$O3hF0:YK&(B ry $B!#(B
$BuFM5/$H%7%J%W%9!JAX(B1$B!K$r7A@.$9$k$3$H$,B?$$!#(B
$B%7%J%W%9(B ( $B%l%$%d(B 1 ) $B7A@.$r?7HiuFM5/$H6&$K$9$k$3$H$,IQHK$G$"$k!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N%U%#!<%I%P%C%/@\B3$,2?$i$+$N7A$N4|BT$^$?$O%P%$%"%9$ruFM5/$X$N0BDj$7$?%U%#!<%I%P%C%/%Q%?!<%s$,!"%7!<%1%s%9Fb$NJ#?t$NMWAG$r$9$Y$FF1;~$KM=B,$G$-$kJ}K!$r<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B
$B?7$7$$%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$,E~Ce$9$k$H!"$=$l$OM=B,%7!<%1%s%9$N0lIt$H$7$F2ruFM5/$X$N2#J}8~$NO"7k$OuFM5/$X$N%H%C%W%@%&%s$NO"7k$OJ#?t$N%7!<%1%s%9MWAG$rF1;~$KM=B,$9$k!#(B
? ry $B!K!"$*$=$i$/?dO@(B ry $B$h$jHyL/$J2ruFM5/$H4pDluFM5/$H$N4V$N@8M}3XE*Aj8_:nMQ$O3hH/$J8&5fJ,Ln$G$"$j!J(BLarkum$B!"(B2013$B!K!"?dO@$dM=B,$K$*$1$k$=$l$i$NLr3d$N$h$j%K%e%"%s%9=E;k$J2ruFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$N%l%Y%k$G5/$3$k!J(BStuart and H sser$B!"(B2001$B!K!#(B

$B@x:_E*%7%J%W%9(B
? $B%K%e!<%m%s$,3hF0$N%Q%?!<%s(B ry $B%Q%?!<%s$G3hF0E*$J:YK&$N%5%V%;%C%H$K@\B3$9$k0lAH$NJBCV(B ry $B!K$rI,MW$H$9$k!#(B
$B%K%e!<%m%s$,%"%/%F%#%S%F%#%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$?$a$K$O!"G'<1$5$l$k%Q%?!<%s$K1w$F%"%/%F%#%V$J:YK&!"$N%5%V%;%C%H$X$H@\B3$9$kJBCV$5$l$?%7%J%W%9!JE57?E*$K$O#1#5$+$i#2#0!K0lAH$rI,MW$H$9$k!#(B


5


? ry $B$5$l$?0lO"$N?7$7$$%7%J%W%9$N7A@.$K$h$C$F(B ry $B!#(B
$B?7$7$$%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$?$a$N3X=,$O!"u%;%0%a%s%H>e$KG[CV$5$l$??7%7%J%W%9$N%;%C%H$NJT@.$K$h$C$FC#@.$5$l$^$9!#(B

? $B?^(B5$B$O!"%7%_%e(B ry $B$*$1$k?7$7$$%7%J%W%9$N7A@.$r%b%G%k2=$9$kJ}K!$r<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B
$B?^(B 5 $B$,<($9$N$O!"%7%_%e%l!<%H$5$l$?(BHTM$B%K%e!<%m%s$K1w$1$k!"?7%7%J%W%9$NJT@.$r!"2f!9$,%b%G%k2=$9$kJ}K!$G$9!#(B
? $B3FuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$K$D$$$F!"u(B ry $B%;%0%a%s%H$H%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$k%M%C%H%o!<%/Fb$NB>$N:YK&$H$N4V$N0lO"$N!V@x:_E*$J!W%7%J%W%9$r0];}$9$k!J(B ry $B!#(B
$BuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$H!"$=$N%;%0%a%s%H$H$N%7%J%W%9$r@x:_E*$K2DG=$H$7$?$=$N%M%C%H%o!<%/FbB>:YK&$H!"$N4V$N!V@x:_E*!W%7%J%W%9%;%C%H$r2f!9$O3FuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$K0];}$9$k!J(BChklovskii et al$B!#!"(B2004$B!K!#(B
$B@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$N?t$O$l$N@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$K2f!9$O3dEv$F$^$9!#(B
? $B%<%m(B ry $BCM$O!"%7%J%W%9(B ry $BFM5/$rI=$7$^$9$,!"$=$l$O@.D9$r;O$a$F$$$^$;$s!#(B
$B%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k2DG=@-$r;}$D<4:w$HuFM5/$H$r!"%<%m$K6a$$1J5WCM$O!"I=$7$^$9$,$=$l$O@.D9$r;O$a$5$;$F$$$^$;$s!#(B
1.0$B$N1JB3CM$O!"Bg$-$J40A4$K7A@.$5$l$?%7%J%W%9$r;}$D<4:w$HuFM5/$rI=$7$^$9!#(B

[$B?^(B5$B$N869F$N=*$o$j$r8+$k(B]

$B1JB3CM$O!"%X%VIw$N5,B'$r;HMQ$7$FA}8:$5$l$^$9!#(B

? $B1JB3CM$,#0!%#3$J$I$NogCM$rD6$($k(B ry $B!#(B
$BogCM(B 0. 3 $BEy$r1JB3CM$,$b$7$bD6$($k>l9g!"%7%J%W%9$N=E$_$O#1$G$"$j!"1JB3CM$,ogCM0J2<$G$"$k>l9g!"%7%J%W%9$N=E$_$O#0$G$"$k!#(B
$BogCM$O%7%J%W%9$N3NN)$rI=$7$^$9$,!"MF0W$K>C$($k2DG=@-$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"$7$-$$CM$N1JB3CM$r;}$D%7%J%W%9$HF1$88z2L$,$"$j$^$9(B ry $B!#(B
$B1JB3CM$,(B1.0$B$N%7%J%W%9$O!"ogCM$J1JB3CM$J%7%J%W%9$HF1$88z2L$r;}$A$^$9$,!"$=$l$[$I4JC1$K$OK:$l$i$l$^$;$s!#(B
$B%9%+%i!<1JB3CM$r;HMQ$9$k$H!"%N%$%:$,$"$k>l9g$N%*%s%i%$%s3X=,$,2DG=$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
$B0JA0$K$O8+$i$l$J$+$C$?F~NO%Q%?!<%s$O%N%$%:$+$b$7$l$^$;$s$^$?$O$=$l$O>-Mh7+$jJV$5$l$k?7$7$$798~$N;O$^$j$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#(B
? ry $B$N$_0[$J$C$F9TF0$9$k!#(B
$B?7$?$J%7%J%W%9$r@.D9$5$;$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$O?7$?$J%Q%?!<%s$K:G=i$KAx6x$7$?$H$-$K$=$l$r3X=,$7;O$a$k$3$H$,$G$-$k$,!"?7$?$J%Q%?!<%s$N$$$/$D$+$NDs<($N8e$K$N$_9TF0$r0[$K$9$k!#(B
? ry $B%Q%?!<%s$,K:$l$k$N$K$h$jD9$$;~4V$,$+$+$k$3$H(B ry $B!#(B
$B$7$-$$CM$rD6$($F1JB3@-$,A}$9$H$$$&$3$H$O!"B>$N$b$N$h$j$b7P83$7$?%Q%?!<%s$OK:$l$k$N$K$h$jD9$/$+$+$k$@$m$&;v$r0UL#$7$^$9!#(B

 ? ry $B%K%e!<%m%s$^$?$O%7%J%W%9$N3h@-(B ry $B!#(B
$B#H#T#M%K%e!<%m%s$*$h$S#H#T#M%M%C(B $B$O!"J,I[$7$?%Q%?!<%s$N:YK&3h@-$K0MB8$7$F$$$k$N$G!"%K%e!<%m%s$NKt$O%7%J%W%9$N$I$A$i$G$"$l3h@-2=6/EY$O$=$l$[$I=EMW$G$O$J$$!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"(BHTM$B%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$G$O!"%K%e!<%m%s$N3h@-2=$H%7%J%W%9$N=E$_$r(B2$BCM>uBV$G%b%G%k2=$7$^$9!#(B
$B$5$i$K!"@8J*3XE*%7%J%W%9$,3NN(O@E*$G$"$k$3$H$O$h$/CN$i$l$F$$$k!J(BFaisal et al$B!#!"(B2008$B!K$N$G!"?7HiuBV$H=E$_$O%Q%U%)!<%^%s%9$r8~>e$5$;$k2DG=@-$,$"$j$^$9$,!"M}O@E*$J4QE@$+$i$OI,?\$G$O$J$/!"$9$Y$F$N%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$O$=$l$i$,$J$/$F$b$&$^$/5!G=$7$F$$$^$9!#(B
HTM$B%M%C%H%o!<%/%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$G;HMQ$5$l$F$$$k@5<0$J3X=,5,B'$O!":`NA$HJ}K!$N%;%/%7%g%s$K5-:\$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B

3$B!#(B $B%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s7k2L(B

$B?^#6$O!"9buFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$r;}$A!"3FuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$O:GBg(B40$B8D$NC$H:G9b$NM=B,@:EY$N$?$a$K9b.8B$G$7$?!#(B
$B$3$N7xO4@-$O!"uFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$,#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$r@8@.$9$k$N$KI,MW$JNL$h$j$bB?$/$N%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k$H$-$K@8$8$k!"A0=R$N%N%$%:BQ@-$K$h$k$b$N$G$"$k!#(B
$B$h$j9b$$%l%Y%k$N:YK&;`$G$O!"%M%C%H%o!<%/@-G=$O:G=i$ODc2<$9$k$,!"$=$N8e%M%C%H%o!<%/$,;D$j$N%K%e!<%m%s$r;HMQ$7$F%Q%?!<%s$r3X=,$9$k$K$D$l$F2sI|$9$k!#(B

4$B!#(B $BF$O@(B

? ry $B$5$l$k%b%G%k%K%e!<%m%s$H$OuFM5/$H2?@i$b$N%7%J%W%9$H$r;HMQ$9$k$3$H$G$9!#$3$l$K$h$j%K%e!<%m%s$O!":YK&$NBg=8CD$NCf$G2?I4$b$N%f%K!<%/%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$^$9!#(B
? $B2f!9$O!"BgNL(B ry $B$G$b!"%K%e!<%m%s$,B?$/$N%Q%?!<%s$r3Nl9g$G$b!"B?$/$N%Q%?!<%s$r%K%e!<%m%s$,3Nc32!"%N%$%:!"$*$h$SJQF0$KBP$7$F%m%P%9%H$G$9!#(B


6


? ry $B$H8F$S$^$9$,(B ry $B!#(B
$B%M%C%H%o!<%/%b%G%k$r!V%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j!W$H2f!9$O8F$S$^$9$,!"uFM5/>e$GG'<1$G$-$k%Q%?!<%s$N?t$H!"$N@Q$H$7$F7W;;$G$-$^$9!#(B
$B$?$H$($P!"(B2$B!s$NNs$,%"%/%F%#%V$G!"3FNs$K(B32$B8D$N%;%k$,$"$j!"3F%;%k$,4pDluFM5/>e$N(B200$B8D$N%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k%M%C%H%o!<%/$G$O!"Ls(B32$BK|8D$NA+0\$r3JG<$G$-$^$9!J!J(B32 / 0.02$B!K(B* 200$B!K!#(B
? $BMFNL$O!"Ns$"$?$j$N%;%k?t$H3F(B ry $B%Q%?!<%s$N?t$KHfNc$7$FA}2C$7$^$9!#(B
$B%+%i%`$"$?$j$N%;%k$N?t$H!"3F%K%e!<%m%s$N4pDl%7%J%W%9$K$h$C$FG'<1$5$l$k%Q%?!<%s$N?t$H!"$KH<$C$FMFNL$O%j%K%"$K%9%1!<%k$7$^$9!#(B


? ry $B!":.Mp$9$k$3$H$J$/FCDj$NF~NO$,0[$J$k;~4VE*>u67$G2?2s8=$l$k$3$H$,$G$-$k(B ry $B!#(B
$BJL$N=EMW$JMFNLB,Dj4p=`$O!"0[$J$k;~4VE*J8L.$K1w$FFCDjC10lF~NO$,:.Mp$J$/8=$l$k;v$,2?2s$G$-$k$+$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#(B
? $B$3$l$O!"FCDj$N2;Dx$,:.Mp$9$k$3$H$J$/%a%m%G%#!<$K8=$l$k2s?t!"$^$?$OFCDj$NC18l$,0[$J$kJ8>O$K2?2s5-21$5$l$k$+$K;w$F$$$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$O!":.Mp$J$/FCDj5YId(B ( $B4V(B ) $B$,%a%m%G%#Fb$K8=$l$k2s?t!"Kt$O0[$J$kJ8$NCf$KFCDjC18l$,2?2s5-$5$l$k$+!"$N%"%J%m%8$H$J$j$^$9!#(B
? $B%_%K%+%i%`$K(B32$B8D$N%;%k$,$"$k>l9g$G$b!"FCDj$N%Q%?!<%s$,(B32$B8D$N0[$J$kI=8=$7$+;}$F$J$$$H$$$&0UL#$G$O$"$j$^$;$s!#(B
$B%;%k(B 32$B8D$r%_%K%+%i%`$,$b$7$b;}$D>l9g$=$l$O!"0[$J$kI=8=(B 32 $B8D$@$1$rFCDj%Q%?!<%s$O;}$D;v$,$G$-$k!";v$r0UL#$7$^$;$s!#(B
$B$?$H$($P!"F~NO$"$?$j(B40$B8D$N%"%/%F%#%VNs!"(B1$BNs$"$?$j(B32$B8D$N%;%k!"(B1$BNs$"$?$j(B1$B8D$N%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$rA[Dj$9$k$H!"3FF~NO%Q%?!<%s$K$O(B3240$B8D$N2DG=$JI=8=$,$"$j!";veL5@)8B$N?t$G$9!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$KF1$8L`EY$G@\B3$G$-$k2DG=@-$,$"$k%;%k%i!<%l%$%d$K$D$$$F$N$_@bL@$7$^$7$?!#(B
$B$3$l$O>.5,LO%M%C%H%o!<%/$G$O$&$^$/5!G=$7$^$9$,!"Bg5,LO%M%C%H%o!<%/$G$O$&$^$/$$$-$^$;$s!#(B
? ry $B$[$H$s$I$NCO0h$,(B y $B!#(B
$B?7Hi.ItJ,$+$i$N$_uFM5/$N%7%J%W%98uJd$rA*Br$9$k$3$H$G!"$3$N$h$&$K9=@.$G$-$^$9!#(B
HTM $B%M%C%H%o!<%/$r$3$NMM$K9=@.$9$k$K$O!"%+%i%`$r(B 2D $B%"%l%$Fb$KG[CV$7!"3FuFM5/$N3F@x:_%7%J%W%9$r%K%e!<%m%sCf?4$J(B 2D$B3NN(J,I[$r;HMQ$7$FA*Br$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$KJT@.$5$l$?(B ry $B!#(B
$B%H%]%m%8E*$KAH?%$5$l$?%M%C%H%o!<%/$O!"G$0U$KBg$-$/$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$^$9!#(B

$B$3$NM}O@$+$iF@$i$l$k8!>Z2DG=$JM=B,$,$$$/$D$+$"$j$^$9!#(B
1$B!K(B
? ry $BE*$KM=B,(B ry $B463P$NN.$l$N4V$KA4BN(B ry $B$J$k$H$$$&](B ry $B!#(B
$BM}O@$O!"O"B3E*M=B,2DG=$J463P%9%H%j!<%_%s%0C10l$N7P2aCf$K1w$F]$K$D$$$F$N%"%k%4%j%:%`E*@bL@$rDs6!$9$k!J(BMartin and Schr er$B!"(B2013; Vinje and Gallant$B!"(B2002; Yen et al$B!#!"(B2007$B!K!#(B
? $B$5$i$K!"M=4|$7$J$$F~NO$,$h$j9b$$%;%k%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$r$b$?$i$9$3$H$rM=B,$7!"$=$l$O%_%K%3%i%`Fb$G?bD>J}8~$KAj4X$5$;$k$Y$-$G$9!#(B
$B99$K$=$l$,M=B,$9$k$N$O!"M=4|$7$J$$F~NO$N7k2L$H$7$F$N!"%_%K%+%i%`Fb$G?bD>J}8~$KAj4X$5$;$k$Y$-$J!"$h$j9b$$%;%k%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$G$9!#(B
$B0lJ}!"M=A[$5$l$kF~NO$O!"%_%K%3%i%`Fb$G$OAj4X$N$J$$%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
$B%_%K%+%i%`$,$3$NM}O@$N87L)$JMW7o$G$O$J$$$3$H$OCmL\$KCM$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B1~Ez$r6&M-$7!"Aj8_$KAK32E*$J>.%0%k!<%W$N:YK&$NB8:_(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$N%b%G%k$O!"%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%I1~Ez6&M-@\B33n$DAj8_M^@)E*!"$J:YK&!"$N3F>.%0%k!<%W$NB8:_$N$_$rI,MW$H$9$k!#(B
? ry $B$H8F$S$^$9$,!"Cl>u$NB&LL(B ry $BL54X78$K$J$k2DG=@-$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N%0%k!<%W$r%_%K%+%i%`$H2f!9$O8F$S$^$9$,!"Cl>u$JB&LL$OI,?\$G$O$J$/!"%0%k!<%W2=$OpJs$r4^$`$H$$$&$3$H$G$9!#(B
$B$3$NM=B,$r;Y;}$9$k=i4|$NZ$9$k$?$a$K$5$i$J$k8&5f$,I,MW$G$"$k!#(B
3$B!K(B
? ry a back action potential.
? ry$B$K5U3hF0EE0L$,B3$/!#(B
$B%7%J%W%92DA:@-$O!"%7%J%W%9F~NO$r2p$7$FC&J,6K$5$l$?uFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$K6I:_2=$5$l$k$Y$-$G$"$j!"$=$N8eC;;~4V8e$K5UEAGE3hF0EE0L(B ( $B5U3hF0EE0L(B ? ) $B$,B3$/!#(B
$B$3$N8=>]$O$^$@9-$/3NN)$5$l$F$$$J$$$,!"$3$N8z2L$OJs9p$5$l$F$$$k!J(BLosonczy et al$B!#!"(B2008$B!K!#(B
4$B!K(B
? ry $B!"$[$H$s$I!"M}A[(B ry $B$@$1B8:_(B ry $B!#(B
$B=jM?$N<4:w$H=jM?$NuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$H$N4V$K7A@.$5$l$k6=J3@-%7%J%W%9$O!"Fs;08D$@$1!"M}A[E*$K$O#1$D$@$1!"B8:_$9$k$O$:$G$"$k!#(B
$B6=J3@-<4:w$,C10l$NuFM5/>e$KHs>o$K6a@\$7$FB??t$N%7%J%W%9$r:n$C$?>l9g!"%7%J%W%9A0:YK&$O(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$r0z$-5/$3$9$3$H$K$*$$$FM%0L$r@j$a$k$G$"$m$&!#(B
? ry $B$,!"<4:wFM5/$,F|>oE*$KC10l(B ry $B%;%0%a%s%H$X$h$j(B ry $B%7%J%W%9$r:n$C$?(B ry $B%(%i!<$K$D$J$,$k!#(B
$BC10l$N<4:w$+$iC10l$NuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$X$N(B2$B!"(B3$B!"$5$i$K$O(B4$B$D$N%7%J%W%9$,5vMF$5$l$k2DG=@-$,$"$k$,!"$h$jB?$/$N%7%J%W%9$rC10l$NuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$X<4:wFM5/$,91>oE*$K:n$C$?>l9g!"$=$l$O%(%i!<$rF3$/!#(B
$B=c?h$J(BHebbian$B3X=,$O!"J#?t$N%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k$N$rB%?J$9$k$h$&$K;W$o$l$k$G$7$g$&!#(B
? ry $B$?$a$K!"2f!9$O(B1$B$D$,3NN)$5$l$?8e$KJ#?t$N%7%J%W%9$N7A@.(B ry $B$rM=B,$9$k!#(B
$B$3$l$,5/$3$i$J$$$h$&$K$9$k0Y$K!"(B 1 $B%7%J%W%93NN)8e$NJ#?t7A@.$r@Q6KE*$KK8$2$k%a%+%K%:%`$NB8:_$r2f!9$OM=B,$9$k!#(B
? $B<4:w$OLdBj$r0z$-5/$3$5$:$KF1$8%K%e!<%m%s$N0[$J$ku(B ry $B>e$K%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k$3$H$,$G$-!"$=$l$f$(2f!9$O$3$N%a%+%K%:%`$,u(B ry $B<4:w%"!<%P!<$N6I=jNN0h$K6u4VE*$K$9$k$3$H$rM=B,$9$k!#(B
$B<4:w$OF1%K%e!<%m%s$NJLuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H>e$X$N%7%J%W%97A@.$rLdBj$r0z5/$3$5$:$G$-$=$l$f$($3$N%a%+%K%:%`$,!"uFM5/%;%0%a%s%HFb$^$?$O<4:wB&;^%m!<%+%k%(%j%"!"$K6u4VE*6I:_$9$k!"$H2f!9$OM=B,$9$k!#(B
5$B!K(B
$B#N#M#D#A(B ry $B$h$C$FC&J,6K$5$l(B ry $B$rAK32$9$k(B ry $B!#(B
$BC&J,6K$r#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$K$h$C$F$5$l$?:YK&$,$=$N8e$K6a0LF~NO$r2p$7$F3hF0EE0L$r@8@.$9$k$H$-!"$=$l$OB>$NA4$F$N6a$/$N6=J3@-:YK&$rM^@)$9$kI,MW$,$"$k!#(B
$B$3$l$OB.$$!"$*$=$i$/C10l$N%9%Q%$%/!"M^@)$rI,MW$H$7$^$9!#(B
? $B9bB.%9%Q%$%/%P%9%1%C%HAK32:YK&(B ry $B$JAK32$N(B ry $B9b$$5/8;$G$9!J(B ry $B!#(B
Fast-spiking $B7?dF:YK&$O!"$3$N5^B.$JM^@)$N:G$b2DG=@-$N9b$$%=!<%9$G$9!J(BHu$B$i!"(B2014$B!K!#(B
6$B!K(B
$B%_%K%3%i%`Fb$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$O!"6&DL$N%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%I1~Ez$r3X$VI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"%_%K%+%i%`Fb$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$rF1;~(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$l$K$O!"%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%I%Q%?!<%s$r3X=,$7$J$,$i!"$=$N%_%K%+%i%`Fb$N3F%;%k=PMh$l$PA4$F$rF1;~$K%"%/%F%#%V$K$9$k$?$a$N%a%+%K%:%`$,I,MW$G$9!#(B
? $BAj8_Ne5/$N$?$a$N$3$NMW7o(B ry $B$N0JA0$NMW7o(B ry $B!#(B
$B6=J3@-Aj8_:nMQ$N$?$a$N$3$NMW7o$O!"#1$D$^$?$OJ#?t$N:YK&$,$o$:$+$KC&J,6K$7$F$$$k$H$-$NAj8_M^@)$N$?$a$N=>MhMW7o$H$OAjH?$9$k$H;W$o$l$k!#(B
$B$3$l$i(B2$B$D$NMW7o$r$I$N$h$&$KK~$?$9$+$K$D$$$F$O!"6qBNE*$JDs0F$O$"$j$^$;$s$,!"NsFb$N%;%k$,Aj8_$K6=J3$7!"B>$N;~$K$OAj8_$KM^@)$5$l$k%a%+%K%:%`$rM=B,$7$^$9!#(B

$B?mBN%K%e!<%m%s$O3$GO$G$O0lHLE*$G$9!#(B
? $B$7$?$,$C$F!";d$?$A$N%K%e!<%m%s$H%M%C%H%o!<%/%b%G%k$N0lIt(B ry $B!#(B
$B8N$K!"%K%e!<%m%s$H%M%C%H%o!<%/$H$N;dC#$N%b%G%k$N0lIt$O3$GO$KEv$F$O$^$k$+$b$7$l$^$;$s!#(B
? ry $B$O5^B.$J3X=,$,CN$i$l(B ry $B%7%J%W%97A@.$K(B ry $B!"?7$7$$%7%J%W%9$N@.D9$H$O(B ry Trachtenberg et al$B!#!K!#$i!"#2#0#0#2G/!K!#(B
$B$7$+$7$J$,$i!"3$GO$O9bB.3X=,$GCN$i$l$F$*$j!"@.?M$G$O%7%J%W%9JT@.$K2?;~4V$b$+$+$k$3$H$,$"$k$?$a!"?7%7%J%W%9$,@.D9$9$k;v$H$OAjMF$l$J$$!J(BHoltmaat and Svoboda$B!"(B2009; Knott et al$B!#!"(B2002; Niell et al$B!#!"(B2004; Trachtenberg $B$i!"#2#0#0#2G/!K!#(B
$B?7$7$$%7%J%W%9$r@.D9$5$;$k$N$G$O$J$/!":YK&$KB??t$NHs3h@-$^$?$O!V%5%$%l%s%H!W%7%J%W%9$,$"$k>l9g!";d$?$A$N%b%G%k$G$O?WB.$J3X=,$,2DG=$K$J$j$^$9!J(BKerchner and Nicoll$B!"(B2008$B!K!#(B
$B$=$N8e!"%5%$%l%s%H%7%J%W%9$r%"%/%F%#%V%7%J%W%9$KJQ$($k$3$H$G!"?WB.$J3X=,$,9T$o$l$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!":YK&$,$5$i$K%7%J%W%9$rI,MW(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$N%"%W%m!<%A$N%^%$%J%9LL$O!"99$KB?$/$N%7%J%W%9$r:YK&$,I,MW$H$9$k$3$H$G$9!#$3$l$OBeZ5r$G$"$m$&!#(B

$B2f!9$NDs0F$7$?@8J*3XE*G[Ns5-215!9=$r5!3#3X=,$NJ,Ln$G;HMQ$5$l$kB>$NG[Ns5-215;=Q$HHf3S$9$k$3$H$OM-1W$G$"$k!#(B
$B:G$b0lHLE*$JuBV$rl9g#H#M#M$h$jM%$l$F$$$k!#(B
? ry $B%M%C%H%o!<%/$H$O0[$J$j!"(B ry $B$h$&$J$b$N$H$7$F!"$=$l$i$O%K%e!<%m%s$^$?$O?7Hi\:Y$K%b%G%k2=$7$h$&$H$O$7$^$;$s!#(B $B$=$N$h$&$J$=$l$i$O!"%K%e!<%m%sE*Kt$O?7Hie$NMxE@(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$l$iN>J}$N5;=Q$KBP$9$k#H#T#M%b%G%k$N\:Y$JHf3S$O(BS1 Table$B$K$"$j$^$9!#(B

? $BB?$/$NO@J8$,G[Ns$NJ8L.$G%9%Q%$%-%s%0(B ry $B%b%G%k$r8&5f(B ry $B!#(B
$B%9%Q%$%-%s%0%K%e!<%m%s%b%G%k$rB?$/$NO@J8$,%7!<%1%s%9J8L.$G8&5f$7$F$$$k!J(BGhosh-Dastidar and Adeli$B!"(B2009; Maass$B!"(B1997$B!K!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N%b%G%k$O!"5!3#3X=,$NJ88%$G;HMQ$5$l$F$$$k%K%e!<%m%s%b%G%k$h$j$b@8J*J*M}3XE*$K>\:Y$G$9!#(B
? $BH`$i$O!"%9%Q%$%/(B ry $B!J#S#T#D#P!K$,!"%7%J%W%9(B ry $B%7!<%1%s%9$*$h$S3F(B ry $BCY1d$KBP$7$F:YK&$,$I$N$h$&$KH?1~$9$k$h$&$K$J$k$+$r<((B ry $B!#(B
$B%7%J%W%9A0%9%Q%$%/$NFCDj%7!<%1%s%9$H$=$7$F3F%9%Q%$%/4V$NFCDj$N;~4VCY1d$H!"$KBP$7$F:YK&$,IR46$K$J$C$F9T$/MM$KM6F3$9$k;v$r%9%Q%$%/%?%$%_%s%00MB82DA:@-(B ( STDP ) $B$,$I$NMM$K$9$l$P$G$-$k$+$rH`$i$O<($7$F$$$k!J#R#a#o$*$h$S#S#e#j#n#o#w#s#k#i!"#2#0#0#0!(#R#u#f$*$h$S#S#c#h#m#i#t#t!"#1#9#9#7!K!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N%b%G%k$O!"$3$N%[%o%$%H%Z!<%Q!<$GDs0F$5$l$F$$$k(BHTM$B%b%G%k$h$j$b>\:YEY$,Dc$/$J$C$F$$$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$7$F$*$j!"BP1~$9$k;~4V(B ry $B!#(B
$B$=$l$i$O%7%J%W%98eEE0L$N@QJ,;~4V$rL@3N$K%b%G%k2=$7$F$*$j!"$=$3$G$N;~4VCY1d$OE57?E*$K%5%V%_%jIC$+$i?t%_%jIC$G$"$k!#(B
? ry $B$^$?!"E57?E*$K$OHs>o$K>.$5$$%7%J%W%9$N%5%V%;%C%H$r07$$!"$=$7$FHs@~7A3h@-uFM5/$rL@<(E*$K%b%G%k2=$7$J$$!#(B
$B$=$l$i$O$^$?!"%7%J%W%9$NHy>.%5%V%;%C%H$rE57?E*$K$O07$$!"$=$7$F%N%s%j%K%"$J%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$rL@<(E*%b%G%k2=$7$J$$!#(B
$B;d$?$A$N;E;v$N>GE@$O$h$j9b$$%l%Y%k$K$"$j$^$7$?!#(B
? ry $B$O!"$=$N$h$&$J%K%e!<%m%s$N%M%C%H%o!<%/2=$5$l$?AX$N!"$=$7$F(B ry $B%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j$N=P8=$N!"%7%J%W%9$H(B ry $BFM5/$N%U%k%;%C%H$N%b%G%k$G$9!#(B
$B$3$NO@J8$GDs<($5$l$?8&5f$O!"%7%J%W%9$H%"%/%F%#%V$JuFM5/$H$N%U%k%;%C%H$=$N$h$&$J%K%e!<%m%s$,%M%C%H%o!<%/2=$5$l$?%l%$%d$N!"$=$7$F7W;;E*$K@vN}$5$l$?%7!<%1%s%95-21$NAOH/$N!"%b%G%k$G$9!#(B
? ry $B$J:YK&AX$N%l%Y%k$G5!G=$9$k@8J*J*M}3XE*$K>\:Y$J%b%G%k(B ry $B!#(B
$B>-Mh$N8&5f$K$H$C$F6=L#?<$$J}8~$O!"$3$l$i(B2$B$D$N%l%Y%k$N%b%G%j%s%0$r7k$SIU$1$k$3$H!"$9$J$o$A40A4$J:YK&%l%$%d$N%l%Y%k$G$N%*%Z%l!<%H$r$9$k>\:Y$J@8J*J*M}3XE*%b%G%k$r:n@.$9$k$3$H$G$9!#(B
$B$$$/$i$+$N?JJb$,Js9p$5$l$F$$$^$9!J(BBillaudelle and Ahmad$B!"(B2015$B!K$,!"$3$NLL$G$d$k$Y$-$3$H$O$^$@$?$/$5$s$"$j$^$9!#(B

? ry $B$*$1$k=EMW$J9MN8;v9`$O!"0lHL2=$NLdBj!"$^$?$O(B ry $B$r7xO4$K=hM}(B ry $B!#(B
$B3X=,%"%k%4%j%:%`$K$*$1$k(B 1 $B$D$N80$H$J$k9MN8;v9`$O!"HL2=$NLdBj$G$9!"Kt$O?75,%Q%?!<%s$r7xO4=hM}$9$kG=NO$G$9!#(B
? ry $B!"$^$P$i$J%Q%?!<%s$NN.$l$NCf$G3hF0E*$J%K%e!<%m%s$N>.$5$$%5%s%W%k$K%7%J%W%9$r7A@.(B ry $B!#(B
$B2f!9$,35@b$7$?%7!<%1%s%95-21%a%+%K%:%`$O!"%9%Q!<%9%Q%?!<%s$N%9%H%j!<%`$NCf$G%"%/%F%#%V%K%e!<%m%s72$N3F>.%5%s%W%k$K%7%J%W%97A@.$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F3X$S$^$9!#(B
$B$^$P$i$JI=8=$N@-o$K=EMW$G$"$j!"=EMW$J0UL#O@E*0UL#$r3FI=8=$,6&M-$9$k$3$H$r0UL#$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$?$a!"%;%0%a%s%H$O?75,$@$,0UL#(B ry $B$9$k%Q%?!<%s$r(B ry $B$7$FG'<1$9$k!#(B
$BuFM5/ogCM$O!"3F%;%0%a%s%H>e$N%7%J%W%9$NGE@$G$9!#(B

5$B!#(B $B:`NA$*$h$SJ}K!(B

? ry $B$N%"%/%F%#%V2=$H3X=,(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$3$G$O!"(BHTM$B%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j%M%C%H%o!<%/$N%"%/%F%#%Y!<%7%g%s$H3X=,$N5,B'$K$D$$$F@5<0$K@bL@$7$^$9!#(B
? $B$3$N5,B'(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N5,B'$K$O!"(B3$B$D$N4pK\E*$JB&LL$,$"$j$^$9!#=i4|2=!"%;%k>uBV$N7W;;!"$*$h$Su%;%0%a%s%H$N%7%J%W%9$N99?7$G$9!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N%9%F%C%W$O!"I=5-K!$*$h$S$$$/$D$+$N\:Y$H$H$b$K!"0J2<$G@bL@$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B

$BI=5-!'(B
N$B$r%l%$%d!uBV!"M=B,!JC&J,6K!K>uBV!"$^$?$OHs3h@->uBV$K$"$jF@$k!#(B
? ry $B!"$=$l$>$l$$$/$D$+$N%7%J%W%9$r;}$D%;%0%a%s%H(B ry $B!#(B
$B3F%;%k$O!"%7%J%W%94v$D$+$rB6!9H<$C$?%;%0%a%s%H$N%;%C%H$r0];}$7$^$9!#(B
? (In this figure we use the term $BET(Bynapse$B!I(B to refer to $BEQ(Botential synapses$B!I(B as described in the body of the paper. Thus at any point in time some of the synapses will have a weight of 0 and some will have a weight of 1.) 
? ry $B$O(B0$B$N=E$_$r;}$A$^$9!#(B 1.$B!K(B
$B!J$3$N?^$G$O!"K\J8$G@bL@$5$l$F$$$k!V@x:_E*%7%J%W%9!W$r;X$9$?$a$K!V%7%J%W%9!W$H$$$&MQ8l$r;HMQ$7$F$$$^$9!#$7$?$,$C$F!"$$$D$G$b%7%J%W%9$N$$$/$D$+$O(B0$B$N=E$_$r;}$A!"$$$/$D$+$N%7%J%W%9$O(B 1 $B$N=E$_$r;}$A$^$9!#(B $B!K(B
? $B$N#2?J%^%H%j%C%/%9(B ry $B#jHVL\$NNs$N(B ry $B!#(B
$BG$0U$N;~4V%9%F%C%W#t$K$*$$$F!"%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$N=89g$O#M%i#N$N%P%$%J%j%^%H%j%C%/%9#A#t$K$h$C$FI=$5$l!"$3$3$G#a#t#i#j$O#jHVL\$N%+%i%`$N#iHVL\$N%;%k$N%"%/%F%#%S%F%#$G$"$k!#(B
$BF1MM$K!"#M%i#N%P%$%J%j9TNs&0#t$O!";~4V#t$K$*$1$kM=B,>uBV$K$"$k%;%k$rI=$7!"$3$3$G!"&P#t#i#j$O!"#jHVL\$NNs$N#iHVL\$N%;%k$NM=B,>uBV$G$"$k!#(B

$B3F%;%k$O!"#D#d#i#j$,#jHVL\$NNs$N#iHVL\$N%;%k$N#dHVL\$N%;%0%a%s%H$rI=$9$h$&$K!"0lAH$N1s0L%;%0%a%s%H#D#i#j$H4XO"IU$1$i$l$k!#(B
? ry $B!"B>$N(BNM-1$B:YK&$N%5%V%;%C%H$+$i$NB&J}7k9g$r(B ry $B!#(B
$B3F1s0L%;%0%a%s%H$O!"B>:YK&(B NM - 1 $B8D$N%5%V%;%C%H$+$i$N2#J}8~@\B3$rI=$9$$$/$D$+$N%7%J%W%9$r4^$`!#(B ?
$B3F%7%J%W%9$O4XO"$9$k1JB3CM$r;}$C$F$$$^$9!JJdB-?^(B2$B;2>H!K!#(B
$B$7$?$,$C$F!"(BDdij$B<+BN$b(BM$B%i(BN$B$N%9%Q!<%99TNs$G$9!#(B
? ry $B$i$l$?%7%J%W%9$,B8:_$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$k>l9g!"9TNs$K$O(B??$B1JB3(B ry $BMWAG$,4^(B ry $B!#(B
$B%;%0%a%s%H$K4XO"IU$1$i$l$?@x:_%7%J%W%9$,B8:_$9$k>l9g!"1JB3CM$rI=$9%<%m0J30$NMWAG(B s $B8D$,9TNs$K4^$^$l$^$9!#(B
$B$=$N1JB3@-$NCM$,@\B3$7$-$$CM$rD6$($F$$$k>l9g!"%7%J%W%9$O@\B3$5$l$F$$$k$H$_$J$5$l$^$9!#(B
~Ddij$B$r;HMQ$7$F!"7k9g%7%J%W%9$N$_$r4^$`%P%$%J%j9TNs$rI=$7$^$9!#(B
1$B!K(B $B=i4|2=!'(B
? ry $B$,AXFb$N%i%s%@%`$KA*Br$5$l$?%;%k$N%5%V%;%C%H(B ry $B!#(B
$B%M%C%H%o!<%/$O!"3F%;%0%a%s%H$,%l%$%dFb$N%;%k$N%i%s%@%`A*Br$5$l$?%5%V%;%C%H$KBP$9$k@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$N%;%C%H!J$9$J$o$A!"%<%m$G$O$J$$1JB3CM!K$r4^$`$h$&$K=i4|2=$5$l$k!#(B
$B$3$l$i$N@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$N1JB3CM$O%i%s%@%`$KA*Br$5$l$^$9!#:G=i$O@\B3$5$l$F$$$k$b$N!J$7$-$$CM$rD6$($k!K$H@\B3$5$l$F$$$J$$$b$N$,$"$j$^$9!#(B

? ry $B7W;;(B
2$B!K(B $B%;%k>uBV$N7W;;(B :
$B%_%K%3%i%`Fb$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$O!"F1$8%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IDj$7$^$9!#(B
$BM^@)%W%m%;%9$,!"8=:_$N%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO%Q%?!<%s$K:G$b$h$/0lCW$9$k(Bk$BNs$N%;%C%H$r$9$G$KA*Br$7$F$$$k$H2f!9$O2>Dj$7$^$9!#(B
$B$3$N=89g$r(BWt$B$H$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$^$9!#(B
$B3F%;%k$N%"%/%F%#%V>uBV$Ol9g$O(B0

$B!J(B2$B!K(B http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#9

? ry $B!">!MxNs$N%;%k$,0JA0$KM=B,>uBV$K$"$C$?>l9g(B ry $B!#(B
$B:G=i$N9T$O!"$=$N>!Mx%+%i%`$N%;%k$,A02s$KM=B,>uBV$@$C$?>l9g$K$=$N%;%k$r%"%/%F%#%V$K$7$^$9!#(B
$B>!MxNs$N%;%k$,$I$l$bM=B,>uBV$K$J$+$C$?>l9g!"(B2$B9TL\$G$=$NNs$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
? $B8=:_$N%?%$%`%9%F%C%W$NM=B,(B ry $B$^$9!#(B
$B8=%?%$%`%9%F%C%W$N0Y$NM=B,>uBV$Ol9g$O(B0

$B!J(B3$B!K(B http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#9

? ry $B!"&A$O(B ry $B!#(B
$BogCM&H$O!"#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/ogCM$rI=$7!"&O$OMWAG$4$H$N>h;;$rI=$9!#(B
? ry $BM-$9$k&H8D$rD6$($k%7%J%W%9$,@\B3$5$l$F$$$k>l9g(B ry $B!#(B
$B=jM?$N;~E@$G!"%"%/%F%#%V%7%J%W%9A0:YK&$rM-$9$k%7%J%W%9$,$b$7$b&H8D$h$j$bB?$/@\B3$7$F$$$k>l9g!"$=$N%;%0%a%s%H$O%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$k!J#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$r@8@.$9$k!K!#(B
$B>/$J$/$H$b(B1$B$D$N%;%0%a%s%H$,%"%/%F%#%V$G$"$l$P!":YK&$OC&J,6K$7$^$9!#(B

? ry $B99?7(B
3$B!K(B $B%;%0%a%s%H$H%7%J%W%9$N99?7(B :
HTM$B%7%J%W%92DA:@-$NK!B'$O!"%X%VIw$N5,B'$G$9!#(B
? ry $B!"0JA0$KC&J,6K(B ry $B!#(B
$B:YK&$,@5$7$/M=B,$5$l$?!J$9$J$o$A!"A02s$KC&J,6K>uBV$K$"$j!"$=$N8e%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$r2p$7$F3h@-$K$J$C$?!K>l9g!"3h@-$G$"$jC&J,6K$r0z$-5/$3$7$?uFM5/%;%0%a%s%H$r2f!9$O6/2=$9$k!#(B
? $B$rA*Br$7$^$9!#(B
$B6qBNE*$K$O!"!$ANs$r(B ry $B!#(B
$B:G=i$N9`$O!"@5$7$$M=B,$,4^$^$l$F$$$k3F>!Mx%+%i%`$rA*Br$7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$K@UG$$,$"$k%;%0%a%s%H$r(B ry $B!#(B
$BBh(B2$B9`$O!"M=B,$KFC$K@UG$$"$k3F%;%0%a%s%H$rA*Br$7$^$9!#(B

? ry $B>!MxNs$,(B ry $B>l9g!"8=:_$N%7!<%1%s%9A+0\$,7+$jJV$5$l$k>l9g!">-Mh%3%s%F%-%9%H$rI=$9%;%k$r(B1$B$DA*Br(B ry $B!#(B
$B>!Mx%+%i%`$,$b$7$bM=B,$5$l$J$+$C$?>l9g!"8=%7!<%1%s%9A+0\$,$b$7$b7+JV$5$l$k>l9g!"$N%3%s%F%-%9%H$r>-MhI=$9$G$"$m$&%;%k(B 1 $B$D!"$r2f!9$OA*Br$9$kI,MW$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $B%"%/%F%#%V$K:G$b(B ry $B$D$^$j$7$-$$CM$r2<2s$C$F$$$F$b:G$b(B ry $B%;%0%a%s%H$r;}$D%;%k$rA*Br$7$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$r9T$&$K$O!"%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$k;v$,:G$b6a$$%;%0%a%s%H!"$D$^$jNc$(=*;OogCML$K~$G$"$l$I:G$bF~NO$,B?$$%;%0%a%s%H!"$r;}$D%;%k$r2f!9$,A*Br$7$^$9!#(B
$B!&(BDdij$B$r(BDdij$B$N@5$NMWAG$N$_$r4^$`(B2$BCM9TNs$H$9$k!#(B
? $B$r6/2=$7$^$9!#(B
$B0J2<$,Ev$F$O$^$k%;%0%a%s%H$r2f!9$,6/2=$7$^$9(B :

 !!!
$B"O!*":(B  ( $B!*(B $B!*(B "= 0 ) $B$+$D(B
    ! $B!*(B !!!
$B!*(B "=$B!*!J!*(B!!!  $B!*!K(B
 ! $B!*(B

$B!J(B5$B!K(B http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#9

? ry $B!#%7%J%W%9$K3hF0E*$J%7%J%W%9A0:YK&$rM?$(!"%7%J%W%9$KIT3h@-$J:YK&$rH3$9$k$3$H$rK>(B ry $B!#(B
$B>e5-$N%;%0%a%s%H$r6/2=$9$k$N$O4JC1$G$9!#%"%/%F%#%V$J%7%J%W%9A0:YK&$rJs=7$H$7$F!"Hs%"%/%F%#%V$J:YK&$rH3$H$7$F!"%7%J%W%9$XM?$($k;v$r2f!9$OK>$_$^$9!#(B
? ry $B$^$9!#(B
$B$=$N$?$a$K!"$9$Y$F$N1JB3CM$r>.$5$$CM(Bp-$B$@$18:$i$7!"%"%/%F%#%V$J%7%J%W%9A0:YK&$KBP1~$9$k1JB3CM$r$h$jBg$-$$CM(Bp +$B$@$1A}$d$7$^$9(B :

!! "=$B!*(B!!" !!! $B!*(B  !!$B!W(B

$B!J(B6$B!K(B http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#9

$B>e5-$N5,B'$O!"8=:_%"%/%F%#%V$J%;%k$r07$$$^$9!#(B
? $B2f!9$O$^$?!"3h@-$K$J$i$J$+$C$?:YK&$N3h@-%;%0%a%s%H$KHs>o$K>.$5$JJx2u$rE,MQ$9$k!#(B
$BHs>o$K>.$5$J8:?j$r!"%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$i$J$+$C$?3F:YK&$N3F%"%/%F%#%V%;%0%a%s%H$K2f!9$OKtE,MQ$9$k!#(B
? ry $B$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$O!"%;%0%a%s%H$,6vA3$K8m$C$FJd6/$5$l$?>l9g$KH/@8$9$k2DG=@-$,$"$j$^$9(B :

 !! "= !!" $B$I$3$G(B
$B!*(B $B!*(B "= 0 and !!" !!!

$B!J(B7$B!K(B http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#9

? $B9TNs(B ry $B$K8=:_$N1JB3CM9TNs$K(B ry $B!#(B
$B3F9TNs&$#D#d#i#j$O!";~4V%9%F%C%W$4$H$K8=1JB3CM9TNsB6!9$K2C;;$5$l$k!#(B

$B\:Y!'(B
$B;d$?$A$N%=%U%H%&%'%"Dj$r$$$/$D$+$7$F$$$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"%i%s%@%`%;%k>e$K%;%0%a%s%H(B ry $B!"8=:_%"%/%F%#%V$J%;%k$+$i(B ry $B!#(B
$B$9$Y$F$N%;%0%a%s%H$*$h$S$9$Y$F$N%;%k$K$o$?$C$F%7%J%W%9$N40A4$J%;%C%H$rL@<(E*$K=i4|2=$9$kBe$o$j$K!"%i%s%@%`$J%;%k$K1w$F%;%0%a%s%H$rlEM_$K:n@.$7!"8=%"%/%F%#%V%;%k72$+$i%5%s%W%j%s%0$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F$=$N%;%0%a%s%H>e$N@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$r=i4|2=$7$^$9!#(B
$B$3$l$O!"4{B8$N%;%0%a%s%H$H0lCW$7$J$$>l9g$K$N$_H/@8$7$^$9!#(B
$B2f!9$N%7%_%e%l!<%7%g%s$G$O!"#N(B $B!a(B $B#2#0#4#8!"#M(B $B!a(B $B#3#2!"#k(B $B!a(B $B#4#0$G$"$k!#(B
? ry $B$r@\B3(B ry $B!#(B
$BDL>o!"%;%0%a%s%H>e$N(B20-40$B8D$N%7%J%W%9$r2f!9$O@\B3$7$^$9!#&H$OLs(B15$B$G$9!#(B
$B1JB3@-$NCM$O!"@\B3$7$-$$CM(B0.5$B$G(B0$B$+$i(B1$B$^$GJQ2=$7$^$9!#(B
p +$B$H(Bp-$B$O8D!9$N%G!<%?%;%C%H$K4p$E$$$FD4@0$5$l$k>.$5$$CM$G$9$,!"DL>o$O(B0.1$BL$K~$G$9!#(B
$Bu(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$N(B10$BG/!#(B
? ry $B!#(B $B7k2L(B $B#8#8!$#2#9#9#1(B^Z$B#3#0#0#1!#(B
$B#J!%#N#e#u#r#o#s#c#i!#%j%=!<%9(B $B#8#8!$(B 2991-3001 $B!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1002 / jnr.22444$B!#(B

Billaudelle$B!"(BS$B!#$H(BAhmad$B!"(BS$B!J(B2015$B!K!#(B
HTM$B%b%G%k$N(BHeidelberg$B%K%e!<%m%b%k%U%#%C%/%3%s%T%e!<%F%#%s%0%W%i%C%H%U%)!<%`$X$N0\?"(B
arXiv$B!'(B1505.02142 [q-bio.NC]

Chklovskii$B!"(BDB$B!"(BMel$B!"(BBW$B!"$*$h$S(BSvoboda$B!"(BK.$B!J(B2004$B!K!#(B
$BHipJs$NJ]B8(B
$B#N#a#t#u#r#e(B $B#4#3#1!"#7#8#2(B-$B#8!#(B
? $BEZ5o!'(B10 ry
doi:10.1038 / nature03012$B!#(B

? ry $B!"#W!%(B $B!J(B2015$B!K(B
$B#C#i#c#h#o#n!"#J!%#a#n#d(B $B#G#a#n!"#W!%(B-B $B!J(B2015$B!K(B
? $BJ,;^FC0[E*u(B ry
$BFCDjJ,;^$Ju(BCa 2+$B%9%Q%$%/$O;}B3E*%7%J%W%92DA:@-$r0z$-5/$3$9(B
$B#N#a#t#u#r#e(B $B#5#2#0!"#1#8#0(B-$B#5!#(B

Cui$B!"(BY.$B!"(BAhmad$B!"(BS.$B!"(BSurpur$B!"(BC.$B!"(Band Hawkins$B!"(BJ.$B!J(B2015$B!K!#(B
$B3hH/$JC5::Cf$K0BDj$7$?CN3P$r0];}$9$k!#(B
? ry $B!K$K(B
Cosyne Abstracts$B!J%=%k%H%l%$%/%7%F%#!K$K1w$F(B

Faisal$B!"(BAA$B!"(BSelen$B!"(BLPJ$B!"$*$h$S(BWolpert$B!"(BDM$B!J(B2008$B!K!#(B
$B?@7P7O$N%N%$%:(B
? Nat$B!#(B $BKR;U!#(B $B#9!$(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Rev. Neurosci. $B#9!$#2#9#2(B-$B#3#0#3!#(B

Ghosh-Dastidar$B!"(BS.$B$*$h$S(BAdeli$B!"(BH.$B!J(B2009$B!K!#(B
$B%9%Q%$%-%s%0%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/(B
Int$B!#(B $B#J!%#N#e#u#r#a#l(B $B#S#y#s#t!#(B $B#1#9!"#2#9#5(B-$B#3#0#8$K5-:\$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

Golding$B!"(BNL$B!"(BJung$B!"(BHY$B!"(BMickus$B!"(BT.$B!"$*$h$S(BSpruston$B!"(BN$B!#!J(B1999$B!K!#(B
$BuFM5/%+%k%7%&%`%9%Q%$%/$N3+;O$H:FJ,6K$O(BCA1$B?mBN%K%e!<%m%s$K$*$1$k0[$J$k%+%j%&%`%A%c%s%M%k%5%V%?%$%W$K$h$C$F@)8f$5$l$k(B
$B#J!%#N#e#u#r#o#s#c#i!#(B  $B#1#9!$#8#7#8#9(B-$B#9#8!#(B

Hawkins$B!"(BJ$B!#!"(BAhmad$B!"(BS$B!#$*$h$S(BDubinsky$B!"(BD$B!#!J(B2011$B!K!#(B
? ry $B;~4V5-21(B
$BHi(B $B9M$($k%3%s%T%e!<%?!<(B
$B%K%e!<%h!<%/!'%X%s%j!<%[%k%H%"%s%I%+%s%Q%K!$K$*$1$k7P830MB8@-$N9=B$E*%7%J%W%92DA:@-(B
? Nat$B!#(B $BKR;U!#(B $B#1#0(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Rev.  Neurosci. $B#1#0!"#6#4#7(B-$B#5#8!#(B

Hu$B!"(BH.$B!"(BGan$B!"(BJ.$B$*$h$S(BJonas$B!"(BP.$B!J(B2014$B!K!#(B
? ry $B%9%Q%$%/%Q%k%V%"%k%V%_%s(B+ ry $B:YK&:YK&(B ry
$B9bB.%9%Q%$%-%s%0(B , $B%Q%k%V%"%k%V%_%s(B+ GABA$B:nF0@-2p:_:YK&(B : $B:YK&@_7W$+$iHy>.$(D??$BsO(B¾$B!G=$^$(B\xC7
? ry 80-$B!#!K(B $B#3#4#5(B ry
$B%5%$%(%s%9!J(B80-$B!#!K(B . $B#3#4#5!$#1#2#5#5#2#6#3(B-$B#1#2#5#5#2#6#3!#(B

? GA$B$N(BKerchner$B!"$*$h$S(BRA$B$N(BNicoll$B!#(B
Kerchner, GA$B!"$*$h$S(BNicoll, RA  (2008)$B!#(B
? ry $B$H(BLTP ry $B$N=P8=(B
$B%5%$%l%s%H%7%J%W%9$H!"(B LTP$B$N0Y$N%7%J%W%98e%a%+%K%:%`$NH/8=(B
? Nat$B!#(B $BKR;U!#(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Rev. Neurosci. $B#9!"#8#1#3(B-$B#2#5!#(B

Knott$B!"(BGW$B!"(BQuairiaux$B!"(BC.$B!"(BGenoud$B!"(BC.$B!"$*$h$S(BWelker$B!"(BE.$B!J(B2002$B!K!#(B
? ry $BuFM5/[y$N7A@.(B
$B@.BN%^%&%9$K$*$$$F%&%#%9%+!<;I7c$K$h$jM6F3$5$l$?(BGABA$B:nF0@-%7%J%W%9$rM-$9$kuFM5/%9%Q%$%s$NJT@.(B
$B%K%e!<%m%s#3#4!"#2#6#5(B-$B#7#3!#(B

Lamme$B!"(BVA$B!"(BSup$BoS!"(BH.$B!"(Band Spekreijse$B!"(BH.$B!J(B1998$B!K!#(B
? ry $B$*$1$k%U%#!<%I(B ry $B%P%C%/=hM}(B
$B;k3PLn$K$*$1$k!"%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%I!"?eJ?$*$h$S%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$N=hM}(B
? Curr$B!#(B $B0U8+(B  $B#N#e#u#r#o#b#i#o#l(B ry $B#5#2#9(B?$B#3#5!#(B
Curr$B!#(B Opin. $B#N#e#u#r#o#b#i#o#l!#(B $B#8!"#5#2#9(B-$B#3#5!#(B

Larkum$B!"(BM.$B!J(B2013$B!K!#(B
$BHiHiu%7%0%J%kEAC#5!9=$K$h$k%7%J%W%9%/%i%9%?%j%s%0(B
? Curr$B!#(B $B0U8+(B $B#N#e#u#r#o#b#i#o#l(B ry $B#3#2#1(B?$B#3#1!#(B
Curr$B!#(B Opin. $B#N#e#u#r#o#b#i#o#l!#(B $B#1#8!"#3#2#1(B-$B#3#1!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1016 / j.conb.2008.08.013$B!#(B

Larkum$B!"(BME$B!"(BNevian$B!"(BT.$B!"(BSandler$B!"(BM.$B!"(BPolsky$B!"(BA.$B$*$h$S(BSchiller$B!"(BJ.$B!J(B2009$B!K!#(B
? ry $B?mBN%K%e!<%m%s$NK<>u(B ry $B%7%J%W%9E}9g?7$7$$E}0l86M}(B
$BBh(B5$BAX?mBN:YK&$NK<>uuFM5/$K$*$1$k%7%J%W%9$NE}9g(B : $B?7$?$JE}0lE*86M}(B
Science 325$B!"(B756-760$B!#(B
? ry 11??71958$B!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1126 / science.1171958$B!#(B

Larkum$B!"(BME$B!"(BZhu$B!"(BJJ$B!"$*$h$S(BSakmann$B!"(BB$B!J(B1999$B!K!#(B
$B0[$J$kHiNs=g=x$NLdBj!W(B
? $B9TF0$NG>$N%a%+%K%:%`$G$O!"JT=8!#(B ry $B!#(B
$B9TF0$K1w$1$kG>%a%+%K%:%`!"JT=8(B L.$B%8%'%U%l%9!J%K%e!<%h!<%/!'%o%$%j!u2DA:(B ry
$B%K%e!<%m%s$K$*$1$k6h2h2=uFM5/2DA:@-$*$h$SF~NOFCD'5-21(B
$B#N#a#t#u#r#e(B $B#4#5#2!"#4#3#6(B-$B#4#1!#(B
$BEZ5o!'(B10.1038 / nature06725$B!#(B

Maass$B!"(BW.$B!J(B1997$B!K!#(B
? ry $B$N%M%C%H%o!<%/%K%e!<%i%k(B ry 
$B%9%Q%$%-%s%0%K%e!<%m%s$N%M%C%H%o!<%/(B : $B%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/%b%G%k$NBh(B3$B@$Be(B
$B%K%e!<%i%k%M%C%H%o!<%/#1#0!"#1#6#5#9(B-$B#1#6#7#1!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1016 / S0893-6080$B!J(B97$B!K(B00011-7$B!#(B

Major$B!"(BG$B!#!"(BLarkum$B!"(BME$B!"$*$h$S(BSchiller$B!"(BJ$B!#!J(B2013$B!K!#(B
? ry $B$N3h@-FC@-(B
$B?7HiuFM5/$NG=F0FC@-(B
? $B%"%s%L!#(B $BKR;U!#(B $B#3#6!$#1(B?$B#2#4!#(B
Annu$B!#(B Rev. Neurosci. $B#3#6!$#1(B-$B#2#4!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1146 / annurev-neuro-062111-150343$B!#(B

? ry $B!"(BJ. and  ry $B!#(B
Major$B!"(BG.$B!"(BPolsky$B!"(BA.$B!"(BDenk$B!"(BW.$B!"(BSchiller$B!"(B J., and Tank$B!"(BDW$B!J(B2008$B!K!#(B
? ry $B$K79uFM5/$K$*$1$k;~6uE*$KEy5i2=$5$l$?(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/(B/$B%W%i%H!J}$KH?1~$7$?%M%30luFM5/>e$G$N%7%J%W%97A@.$N(Bin vivo$B%$%a!<%8%s%0(B
? Nat$B!#(B $B?@7P>I!#(B $B#7!$(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Neurosci. $B#7!$#2#5#4(B-$B#6#0$K5-:\$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

Nikoli$B!"(BD.$B!"(BH$BcT(Bsler$B!"(BS.$B!"(BSinger$B!"(BW.$B$*$h$S(BMaass$B!"(BW$B!J(B2009$B!K!#(B
? ry $BHiu(B ry 
$B?mBN:YK&$N(B thin $BuFM5/$K$*$1$k7W;;%5%V%f%K%C%H(B
? Nat$B!#(B $B?@7P>I!#(B $B#7(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Neurosci. $B#7!$#6#2#1(B-$B#7!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1038 / nn 1253$B!#(B

Rabiner$B!"(BL$B!#$*$h$S(BJuang$B!"(BB$B!J(B1986$B!K!#(B
$B1#$l%^%k%3%U%b%G%k$N>R2p(B
IEEE ASSP Mag$B!#(B $B#3!$#4(B^Z$B#1#6!#(B

? ry $B#J!%(B ? $B#C(B ry $B!"#B!#(B  $B!J(B2013$B!K!#(B
$B#R#a#h!"#J!%(B - $B#C!%!"#B#a#s!"#E!%!"#C#o#l#o#n#e#l#l!"#J!%!"#M#i#s#h#c#h#e#n#k#o!"#Y!%!"#K#a#r#s#h!"#B!#(B , Fetter, R. D., et al. $B!J(B2013$B!K!#(B
? $BDjNL(B ry $B%H%b%0%i%U%#!<$rMQ$$$FB,Dj$5$l$?AX(B5$B?mBN(B ry $B$X$N;k>2(B ry
$B%l%$%d(B 5 $B?mBN%K%e!<%m%s$X$NDjNLE*Bg5,LO%"%l%$%H%b%0%i%U%#!2Hi^Z$B#1#7#0$K$*$1$k?JJb$K$*$$$F!#(B
$B%K%e!<%i%k>pJs=hM}%7%9%F%`$K$*$1$k?JJb$K$*$$$F(B $B#1#2!"#1#6#4(B-$B#1#7#0!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1.1.45.9739$B!#(B

Ruf$B!"(BB.$B$*$h$S(BSchmitt$B!"(BM.$B!J(B1997$B!K!#(B
? $B%9%Q%$%/%K%e!<%m%s$N%M%C%H(B ry
$B%9%Q%$%-%s%0%K%e!<%m%s%M%C%H%o!<%/$K$*$1$k;~4VE*Id9f2=%Q%?!<%s$N3X=,(B
? ry $B%W%m%;%9(B $B!"(B9 ry
$B?@7P%W%m%;%9(B Lett. $B!"(B9-18$B!#(B
doi$B!'(B10.1023 / A$B!'(B1009697008681$B!#(B

Schiller$B!"(BJ$B!#!"(BMajor$B!"(BG$B!#!"(BKoester$B!"(BHJ$B!"$*$h$S(BSchiller$B!"(BY$B!#!J(B2000$B!K!#(B
$BHiuFM5/$K$*$1$k(BNMDA$B%9%Q%$%/(B
$B#N#a#t#u#r#e(B $B#4#0#4!"#2#8#5(B?$B#9!#(B

Schiller$B!"(BJ$B!#$*$h$S(BSchiller$B!"(BY.$B!J(B2001$B!K!#(B
? ry $BCg2pu(B ry
NMDA$BuFM5/%9%Q%$%/$HF1;~%7%0%J%kA}I}(B
Curr$B!#(B $B0U8+(B $B#N#e#u#r#o#b#i#o#l!#(B $B#1#1!$#3#4#3(B-$B#8!#(B

Spruston$B!"(BN.$B!J(B2008$B!K!#(B
? ry $B%K%e!<%m%su(B ry
$B?mBN%K%e!<%m%s(B : $Bu9=B$$H%7%J%W%9E}9g(B
? Nat$B!#(B $BKR;U!#(B $B#9!$#2#0#6(B?$B#2#1(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Rev. Neurosci. $B#9!$#2#0#6(B-$B#2#1$K5-:\$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

Stuart$B!"(BGJ$B!"(Band H$BcT(Bsser,$B!"(BM.$B!J(B2001$B!K!#(B
EPSP$B$NuFM5/F1;~8!=P$H3hF0EE0L(B
? Nat$B!#(B $B?@7P>I!#(B $B#4!"#6#3(B?$B#7#1!#(B
Nat$B!#(B Neurosci. $B#4!"#6#3(B-$B#7#1!#(B

Stuart$B!"(BGJ$B!"(Band H$BcT(Bsser$B!"(BM.$B!J(B2001$B!K!#(B
? EPSP$B$Nu(B ry $B8!=P$H3hF0EE0L(B
EPSP $B$N$H3hF0EE0L$N$H$NuFM5/F1;~8!=P(B
? Nat$B!#(B $B?@7P>I!##4!"(B ry
Nat$B!#(B Neurosci. $B#4!"#6#3(B-$B#7#1!#(B


11


? ry $B!"(BE$B!#(B $B!J(B ry $B!#(B
Trachtenberg$B!"(BJT$B!"(BChen$B!"(BBE$B!"(BKnott$B!"(BGW$B!"(BFeng$B!"(BG.$B!"(BSanes$B!"(BJR$B!"(BWelker$B!"(B E., et al.  $B!J(B2002$B!K!#(B
? ry $B$ND94|(Bin ry
$B@.BNHipJsEAC#8zN($r9b$a$k(B
$B#J!%#N#e#u#r#o#s#c#i!#(B $B#2#2!"#2#9#0#4(B-$B#2#9#1#5$K5-:\$5$l$F$$$k!#(B

Yen$B!"(BS.-C.$B!"(BBaker$B!"(BJ.$B!"(Band Grey$B!"(BCM$B!J(B2007$B!K!#(B
? ry $B%K%e!<%m%s$NH?1~$NIT6Q0l@-(B
$B%M%3@~>rHiF~NO$N@-uFM5/$b$"$j$^$;$s!#(B
B$B!K(B
$B?7HiuFM5/>e$K0LCV$9$k2?@i$b$N6=J3@-%7%J%W%9$rM-$9$k!JA^F~?^!K!#(B
? ry $B>e$N0lO"$N%7%J%W%9$NF1;~3h@-2=$O!"BN:YK&$G#N#M#D#A(B ry $BC&J,6K$r0z$-5/$3$9(B ry $B!#(B
$BuFM5/%;%0%a%s%H>e$N%7%J%W%9$N%;%C%H$NF1;~3h@-2=$O!"#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$*$h$SC&J,6K$r:YK&BN>e$G0z5/$3$9$G$"$m$&!#(B
$B%;%k$X$NF~NO$K$O(B3$B$D$N%=!<%9$,$"$j$^$9!#(B
$BBN:YK&$N6a$/$K%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO!JNP?'$G<($9!K$O!"3hF0EE0L$KD>@\$D$J$,$k!#(B
? ry $B1s0L$N4pDluFM5/$*$h$SD:C<uFM5/$KH/@8$7$?#N#M#D#A(B ry $B$OBN:YK&(B ry $B$K$OBN@-3hF0EE0L(B ry $B!#(B
$B$h$j1s0L$J4pDl5Z$S@mC<$NuFM5/$K$F@8@.$5$l$?#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$O:YK&BN$rC&J,6K$9$k$,!"E57?E*$K$O:YK&BN3hF0EE0L$rH/@8$5$;$k$N$K==J,$G$O$J$$!#(B
C$B!K(B
? $B#H#T#M%b%G%k%K%e(B  $B$OuuFM5/$*$h$S#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$r$=$l$>$l0lAH$N%7%J%W%9$rM-$9$kF1;~8!=P4o$N%"%l%$$rMQ$$$F%b%G%k(B ry $B$7$+<($5$l(B ry $B!#(B
$BF1;~8!=P4oB6!9%7%J%W%9(B 1 $B%;%C%HIU$N%"%l%$!"$rH<$C$?(B HTM $B%b%G%k%K%e!<%m%s$O!"(B $BuFM5/$H(B NMDA $B%9%Q%$%/$H$r%b%G%k2=$9$k!J$=$l$>$l?t8D$7$+?^<($5$l$F$$$J$$!K!#(B


? 13$BG/(B



A $B:YK&AX$O%7!<%1%s%9$r3X$V(B

        2/3     4       5       6
         $B"-(B


? B $B3X$VA0$K(B
B $B3X=,A0(B

        A       B       C       D               ? $B$"$$$&$($*(B
        X       B       C       Y

        $B!!(B $B"-"-(B $B"-(B
$BF1$8Ns$G$9$,!"Ns$4$H$K%"%/%F%#%V$J%;%k$O(B1$B$D$@$1$G$9!#(B
        $B!!(B $B"-"-(B $B"-(B

C $B3X$s$@8e(B

        A       B'      C'      D'              ? $B$"$$$&$($*(B'
        X       B "        C "        Y"


? ry $BHil9g!"$=$N%_%K%+%i%`Fb$NA4%;%k$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j$^$9!#$3$l$O!"$=$N%7!<%1%s%9$r3X=,$9$kA0$N>l9g$G$9!#(B
C$B!K(B
 ry $B!"F~NO(B ry $B$5$l$?(B1$B$D$N%;%k$N$_$,3FNs$G%"%/%F%#%V$G$9!#(B
2$B$D$N%7!<%1%s%9$r3X=,$7$?8e!"$=$l$iF~NO$OF1$8%_%K%+%i%`$r5/F0$7$^$9$,!"(BB '$B!"(BB' '$B!"(BC'$B!"(BC ''$B!"(BD '$B$*$h$S(BY' '$B$H%i%Y%kIU$1$5$l$?3FNs$NCf$K1w$F(B 1 $B%;%k$N$_$,%"%/%F%#%V$G$9!#(B
C '$B$H(BC' '$B$O0l0U$G$"$k$?$a!"(BY$B$^$?$O(BD$B$N$I$A$i$+$N@5$7$$9bJ}$,<($5$l$k!#(B
$B:G=i$N%Q%M%k$K$OM=4|$7$J$$F~NO(BA$B$,I=<($5$l!"$=$l$,C%;%k(B ry $B!#(B
$B8eB3$NF~NO$,M=B,$H0lCW$9$k>l9g!"C&J,6K%;%k$N$_$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j!J(B3$BHVL\$N%Q%M%k!K!"$3$l$,?7$7$$M=B,$K$D$J$,$j$^$9!J(B4$BHVL\$N%Q%M%k!K!#(B
? ry $B$5$l$k30B&%7%J%W%97k9g$,:G$b(B ry $B!#(B
$BM=B,$5$l$?:YK&$N$&$A$N#1$D$K$h$C$F;HMQ$5$l$k%7%J%W%92#J}8~@\B3J#?t$,:G$b1&B&$N%Q%M%k$K<($5$l$F$$$k!#(B
? ry $B$O!"B??t$N%"%/%F%#%V%;%k$N%5%V%;%C%H(B ry $B!#(B
$B8=e$N@\B3$r;}$D$3$H$K$J$j$^$9!#(B
B$B!K(B
$B$"$$$^$$$J%5%V%7!<%1%s%9!V#B#C!W!J$3$l$O#A#B#C#D$*$h$S#X#B#C#Y$NN>J}$N0lIt$G$"$k!K$,%M%C%H%o!<%/$KDs<($5$l$k!#(B 
$B:G=i$N%Q%M%k$OM=4|$7$J$$F~NO(BB$B$r<($7$F$*$j!"$3$l$O(BC '$B$H(BC' '$B$NN>J}$NM=B,$K$D$J$,$j$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!#N>J}$N%;%C%H$NM=B,%;%k$,%"%/%F%#%V(B ry $BM=B,$7$^$9!J(B4$BHVL\$N%Q%M%k!K!#(B
3$BHVL\$N%Q%M%k$O!"F~NO(BC$B$N8e$N%7%9%F%`$r<($7$F$$$^$9!#M=B,%;%k%;%C%H$NN>J}$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j!"(BD$B$H(BY$B$NN>J}$rM=B,$7$F$$$^$9!J(B4$BHVL\$N%Q%M%k!K!#(B
$BJ#;($J%G!<%?%9%H%j!<%`$G$O!"DL>oB?$/$NF1;~M=B,$,$"$j$^$9!#(B


? 15$BG/(B



$B@hC<uFM5/(B

$B%7!<%1%s%9(BB 'C' D '$B$N%U%#!<%I%P%C%/%P%$%"%9(B


$B"+(B $BF~NO(BC
$BI=8=(BC '


$B"+(B $BF~NO(BY
$B4|BT$H0lCW$7$^$;$s(B


? ry $B@hC<u(B ry $B$OA4G[Ns$r(B ry $B!#(B
$B?^#4!'(B $B@mC<uFM5/$X$N%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$O%7!<%1%s%9A4BN$rM=B,$9$k!#(B
$B$3$N?^$O!"?^#2$HF1$8%M%C%H%o!<%/$*$h$SI=8=$r;HMQ$7$F$$$k!#(B
$B!V@hC<uFM5/!W$HI=<($5$l$?NN0h$O!"?7HiuFM5/!J?^<($;$:!K$O$3$3$G=*7k$9$k!#(B
$B?^$G$O!"Dj$5$l$F$$$^$9!#(B
? ry $B<($5$l$F$$$k$h$&$K!"%M%C%H%o!<%/$O0JA0$K%7!<%1%s%9(B ry $B$r3X=,$7$?!#(B
$B?^#2$K<($5$l$?%7!<%1%s%9#A#B#C#D$r%M%C%H%o!<%/$O0JA0$K3X=,$7$?!#(B
? $B3X=,$5$l$?%7!<%1%s%9$N4V!"D:C<uFM5/$K0lDj$N%U%#!<%I%P%C%/%Q%?!<%s$,Ds<($5$l!"G[Ns(BB'C'D '$B$K;22C$9$k:YK&$O$=$l$i$ND:C<uFM5/>e$K%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$7$F0lDj$N%U%#!<%I%P%C%/%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$7$?!#(B
$B3X=,:Q%7!<%1%s%9$KOK$C$F@mC<uFM5/$X$HDs<($5$l(B ( $B$F$$(B ) $B$k%3%s%9%?%s%H$J%U%#!<%I%P%C%/%Q%?!<%s!"$r$=$7$FG'<1$9$k0Y$K%7!<%1%s%9(B B'C'D ' $B;22C3F:YK&$O$=$l$i@mC<uFM5/>e$K%7%J%W%9JT@.$7$?!#(B

$B%U%#!<%I%P%C%/@\B3$,3X=,$5$l$?8e!"D:C<uFM5/$X$N%U%#!<%I%P%C%/%Q%?!<%s$NDs<($O!"%7!<%1%s%9Fb$G=gC>uBV$K$J$j$^$9!J(B ry $B!#(B
$B@V$GI=<($5$l$F$$$k$3$l$i$N%;%k$O!"C&J,6K$7$^$9!J:8%Z%$%s!K!#(B
$B?7$7$$%U%#!<%I%U%)%o!<%IF~NO$,E~Ce$9$k$H!"M=B,$5$l$?%7!<%1%s%9$K4XO"$9$k%9%Q!<%9I=8=$K$J$j$^$9!JCf1{$N%Q%M%k!K!#(B
? ry $B%Q%?!<%s$,M=A[$5$l$k%7!<%1%s%9$N0lIt$H$7$F2rl9g!J1&%Q%M%k!K!"A*Br$5$l$?%+%i%`$N$9$Y$F$N%;%k$,%"%/%F%#%V$K$J$j!"0[>o$r<($7$^$9!#(B
? ry $B!"D:C<%U%#!<%I%P%C%/$O!"M=A[$5$l$k%7!<%1%s%9$N0lIt$H$7$FF~NO$r2rl9g$r8!=P$9$k!#(B


16



$BuFM5/(B

$B<4:w(B

        0.0     0.3             1.0
                                $B%7%J%W%9!V1JB3@-!W(B
            0             1
                        ? $B%7%J%W%9=ENL(B
                        $B%7%J%W%9%&%'%$%H(B


? ry $B?7$7$$%7%J%W%9(B ry
$B?^(B5$B!'?7%7%J%W%9$N@.D9$K$h$k3X=,(B
? ry $B!"0lO"$N@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$+$i$N?7$7$$%7%J%W%9(B ry $B!#(B
HTM$B%K%e!<%m%s$G$N3X=,$O!"@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$N%;%C%H$+$i$N?7%7%J%W%9$N@.D9$K$h$C$F%b%G%k2=$5$l$^$9!#(B
$B!V1JB3@-!WCM$O3F@x:_E*%7%J%W%9$K3d$jEv$F$i$l!"%7%J%W%9$N@.D9$rI=$7$^$9!#(B
$B3X=,$O!"1JB3@-$NCM$rA}8:$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F9T$o$l$^$9!#(B
? ry $B=E$_$O!"1JB3(B ry $B@_Dj$5$l$?%P%$%J%jCM$G$9!#(B
$B%7%J%W%9$N=E$_$O%P%$%J%jCM$G!"1JB3@-$,$7$-$$CM$rD6$($F$$$k>l9g$O(B1$B$K@_Dj$5$l$^$9!#(B


? 17$BG/(B



A

$B@53N$5(B
60$B!s(B
$B!'(B               $B0l/?t$N%7%J%W%9$GBg$-$J%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$9$k$H$-$N8m$j$N2DG=@-(B

$B8m$j$N2DG=@-$r7W;;$9$k$?$a$N8x<0(B
? ry $B!J%7%J%W%9$r7A@.(B ry $B!#(B
$BHs@~7Au%;%0%a%s%H$O!"Bg$-$J=8CD$+$i$N>/?t$N:YK&$r%5%V%5%s%W%j%s%0$9$k!J$=$NMM$K%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k!K$3$H$K$h$C$F%Q%?!<%s$r%m%P%9%H$KJ,N`$9$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B
? ry $B8m$C$?0lCW(B ry $B$^$9!#(B
$B%Q%?!<%s$,%i%s%@%`$KJ,I[$7$F$$$k$H2>Dj$9$k$H!"0J2<$N<0$G8m0lCW$N@53N$J3NN($,5a$a$i$l$^$9(B : http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:arxiv.org/pdf/1511.00083#19


^Z ^Z^Z^Z ^Z!!!! ! ! $B%i(B ! ! ^Z ^Z^Z^Z   ^Z ! ! ^Z

n = $B:YK&=8CD$NBg$-$5(B
a = $B%"%/%F%#%V%;%k?t(B
? ry $B%;%0%a%s%H$N(B ry
s = $B%;%0%a%s%H>e$N%7%J%W%9?t(B
$B&H(B = NMDA$B%9%Q%$%/$7$-$$CM(B



$BI=(BA$B!'(B $B%5%V%5%s%W%j%s%0$K$h$k8m:9$N2DG=@-(B

$B$3$NI=$O!">e5-$N<0$r;HMQ$7$F!"8m$C$?0lCW$N2DG=@-$KBP$9$k%5%V%5%s%W%j%s%0$N8z2L$r<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B
$B%5%s%W%j%s%0%5%$%:$,Bg$-$/$J$k$K$D$l$F!"%(%i!<$N2DG=@-$O5^B.$KDc2<$7$^$9!#(B
$B?.Mj@-$N9b$$%^%C%A%s%0$K$O!">/?t$N%7%J%W%9$G==J,$G$9!#(B


s       $B8m$C$?0lCW$N2DG=@-(B

6       9.9 $B%i(B 10 ^ -13
8       9.9 $B%i(B 10 ^ -17
10      9.9 $B%i(B 10 ^ -21

n = 200,000
a = 2,000
$B&H(B = s



$BI=(BB : 50$B!s$N%N%$%:BQ@-$rDI2C$7$?>l9g$N%(%i!<$N2DG=@-(B

$B$3$NI=$O!"%N%$%:$KBP$9$k7xO4@-$r<($7$F$$$^$9!#(B
$B#N#M#D#A%9%Q%$%/$KI,MW$H$5$l$k$h$j$bB?$/$N%7%J%W%9$r7A@.$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"%K%e!<%m%s$O!"BgNL$N%N%$%:$*$h$S%Q%?!<%s$NJQF0$KBP$7$F%m%P%9%H$G$"$jF@!"$=$l$G$b$J$*!"8m$C$?0lCW$N2DG=@-$,Dc$$!#(B
$BNc$($P!"#s(B $B!a(B $B#2&H$N>l9g!"%7%9%F%`$O#5#0!s$N;(2;$KBP$7$FBQ@-$,$"$k!#(B
? $B%(%i!<(B ry $B$OA}2C(B ry $B$D$l$F5^B.(B ry $B$7$^$9!#(B $B%N%$%:(B ry $B$K$O>/?t$N%7%J%W%9$G==J,$G$9!#(B
$B%N%$%:$,$"$C$F$b!"?.Mj@-$N9b$$%^%C%A%s%0$K$O!"%7%J%W%9>/?t$G=e$N:.9g%7%J%W%9$NDI2C(B ry
$BI=(BC$B!'(B $Bu%;%0%a%s%H>e$G$N%7%J%W%9:.8r$NDI2C$K$h$k8m$j$N2DG=@-(B

? $B$3$NI=$O!"C10l(B ry $B$N:.9g$,0MA3$H$7$F5vMF$G$-$J$$%(%i!<(B ry $B!#(B
$B$3$NI=$O!"5vMFIT2D$J%(%i!<$rC10lu%;%0%a%s%H>e$N#m8D$N0[$J$k%Q%?!<%s$KBP$9$k%7%J%W%9$N:.8r$,0MA3$H$7$F0z5/$3$5$J$$$3$H$rZ$7$F$$$k!#(B
? ry $BG'<1$7!"$J$*#5#0!s$N%N%$%:$KBP$7$F%m%P%9%H$G$"$jF@$k$+$r8+$k(B ry $B!#(B
$B#s(B $B!a(B $B#2#m&H$K@_Dj$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"%;%0%a%s%H$,$I$N$h$&$K$7$F#m8D$NFHN)$7$?%Q%?!<%s$rG'<1$7>0(B 50 % $B$N%N%$%:$KBP$7$F%m%P%9%H$G$"$jF@$k$+!"$r2f!9$O8+$k$3$H$,$G$-$k!#(B
$B$o$:$+$K9b$$$7$-$$CM$r;HMQ$9$k$3$H$K$h$C$F!"$h$jBg$-$$(Bm$B$GHs>o$K9b$$@:EY$rF@$k$3$H$,2DG=$G$9!#(B

$B&H(B
m               ? $B%a!<%H%k(B
s
$B8m$C$?0lCW$N2DG=@-(B

10      2       40      6.3 $B%i(B 10 ^ -12
10      4       80      8.5 $B%i(B 10 ^ -9
10      6       120     4.2 $B%i(B 10 ^ -7
15      6       120     1.7 $B%i(B 10 ^ -12

n = 200,000
a = 2,000


? 19$BG/(B



$B9bo$K9b$$(B
        HMM     $B$$$$$((B
        LSTM    $B$O$$(B

$B?@7P2J3X$X$N>\:Y$J%^%C%T%s%0(B
        HTM     $B$O$$(B
        HMM     $B$$$$$((B
        LSTM    $B$$$$$((B

$B3NN(%b%G%k(B
        HTM     $B$$$$$((B
        HMM     $B$O$$(B
        LSTM    $B$$$$$((B


S1$B%F!<%V%k!"6&DL%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j%"%k%4%j%:%`$NHf3S(B
2$B$D$N6&DL%7!<%1%s%9%a%b%j%"%k%4%j%:%`!J(BHMM$B$H(BLSTM$B!K$rDs0F%b%G%k!J(BHTM$B!K$HHf3S$7$?I=!#(B
*$B%&%'%$%H99?7%k!<%k$O%m!<%+%k$G$9$,!"(BLSTM$B$G$O%0%m!<%P%k%(%i!




Fnews-brouse 1.9(20180406) -- by Mizuno, MWE <mwe@ccsf.jp>
GnuPG Key ID = ECC8A735
GnuPG Key fingerprint = 9BE6 B9E9 55A5 A499 CD51 946E 9BDC 7870 ECC8 A735