> I really don't get the lukewarm reception

Remember how badly everyone ragged on the DS? The "gimmicky" design?
And now that there are a few good titles out there, what do people say?

Gamers can be just as conservative as any other group. They fear what
they don't understand. It took a while for them to understand the DS,
but now they get it. Right now, they don't understand the Revolution.
Once we have good games that use it, they'll accept it. Well, except
the trolls.