Eric Takabayashi <etakajp@yahoo.co.jp> wrote:
> mtfester@netMAPSONscape.net wrote:

>> Eric Takabayashi <etakajp@yahoo.co.jp> wrote:
>> > Scott Reynolds wrote:
>>
>> >> What would you consider an appropriate punishment for them?
>>
>> > The US and US soldiers responsible for committing crimes such as the abusers of Abu
>> > Ghraib should be treated or punished the way they would treat or punish their
>> > detainees, held without charge or trial.
>>
>> Ah, this one again.
>>
>> Uh, if you don't try or charge them, how do you already know they're
>> responsible?

> Because those who are responsible, are responsible. My knowing or not knowing are
> irrelevant.

So, without trial or charge, you round up the "responsible" (in some
magical fashion) and punish them without charge, for a specific crime.

Even for you, this is a bit surreal...

Mike